Skip to content


The Union of India Vs. Shri N Srinivasulu - Court Judgment

LegalCrystal Citation
CourtKarnataka High Court
Decided On
Case NumberWP 51098/2016
Judge
AppellantThe Union of India
RespondentShri N Srinivasulu
Excerpt:
1 r in the high court of karnataka at bengaluru dated this the16h day of november2016present the hon’ble mr.justice jayant patel and the hon’ble mr.justice sreenivas harish kumar writ petition no.51098/2016 & writ petition nos. 54922-55037/2016 (s-cat) c/w writ petition no.53273/2016 & writ petition nos.54819-54917/2016 (s-cat) c/w writ petition no.53277/2016 & writ petition nos.54817-818/2016 (s-cat) writ petition nos.53575-53577/2016 (s-cat) c/w in w.p.no.51098/2016 & w.p.nos.54922-55037/2016 between1the union of india represented by its secretary to govt. of india, ministry of finance, department of expenditure2north block, new delhi-110 001. 2.the ministry of personnel public grievances and pensions, represented by its secretary to government of india, department of personnel and.....
Judgment:

1 R IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE16H DAY OF NOVEMBER2016PRESENT THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE JAYANT PATEL AND THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE SREENIVAS HARISH KUMAR WRIT PETITION NO.51098/2016 & WRIT PETITION NOS. 54922-55037/2016 (S-CAT) C/W WRIT PETITION NO.53273/2016 & WRIT PETITION NOS.54819-54917/2016 (S-CAT) C/W WRIT PETITION NO.53277/2016 & WRIT PETITION NOS.54817-818/2016 (S-CAT) WRIT PETITION NOS.53575-53577/2016 (S-CAT) C/W IN W.P.NO.51098/2016 & W.P.NOS.54922-55037/2016 BETWEEN1THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVT. OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF FINANCE, DEPARTMENT OF EXPENDITURE2NORTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI-110 001. 2.THE MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL PUBLIC GRIEVANCES AND PENSIONS, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL AND TRAINING, NEW DELHI-110 001. 3.THE MINISTRY OF DEFENCE (FINANCE) REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, ESTABLISHMENT-1 SECTION, NEW DELHI-110 001. 4.THE CONTROLLER GENERAL OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS, ULAN BATAR ROAD, PALAM, DELHI CANTT-110 010. 5.THE PRINCIPAL CONTROLLER OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS, LOWER AGRAM RAOD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007. 6.CONTROLLER OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS (R&D) C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 093. 7.CONTROLLER OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS (SR) REGIONAL TRAINING CENTRE, DRDO PHASE-II, KAGGADASAPURA, C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 093. 8.CONTROLLER OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS NO.618, ANNA SALAI, TEYNAMPET, CHENNAI-600 018. 9.JOINT CONTROLLER OF3DEFENCE ACCOUNTS (AF) VAYUSENA NAGAAR, NAGPUR-440 007. 10.INTEGRATED FINANCIAL ADVISER (COAST GUARD) NATIONAL STADIUM COMPLEX, NEW DELHI-110 001 ... PETITIONERS (BY SRI SHASHIKANTHA C, CGC) AND1SHRI N SRINIVASULU AAO,A/C No.8336500, AGED ABOUT40YEARS S/O SHRI N SUBBARAYUDU, O/O THE PCDA,NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-07 R/O B-15/9, DAD RESI.COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008 2.N CHANDRASEKAR AAO, A/C NO.8317424, AGED ABOUT57YEARS S/O LATE G M NARAYANA REDDY, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O NO.24,3RD CROSS,2ND MAIN, BALAJI NAGAR, DHARMARAM COLLEGE POST, BANGALORE-29 4 3.SHRI R RAVINDRA BABU AAO, A/C NO.8334218, AGED ABOUT42YEARS S/O SHRI R C VEERANNA, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O B-2/6, DAD RESI.COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008 4.SHRI U SURENDRA PAI AAO/8336637, AGED ABOUT50YEARS S/O SHRI U SITARAM PAI, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O G-4, A BLOCK,SRIVEN SPLENDOUR, CHALLAGHATTA, BANGALORE-560 037 5.SHRI K V SRINIVASA RAO AAO/8336267, AGED ABOUT51YEARS S/O SHRI K.V.N.RAO, O/O PAO(ORS)ASC(AT) LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O C-17/21,DAD RESI.COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008 6.SHRI P L SRINIVAS5AAO/8336292, AGED ABOUT40YEARS, S/O SHRI P V L N RAO, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O B-1/15, DAD RESI.COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008 7.SHRI C V SUDHAKARA REDDY AAO, A/C833440, AGED ABOUT41YEARS, S/O C V SUBBA REDDY, O/O THE PCDA,NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O B-3/2, DAD RESI.COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008 8.SHRI K VISHNU MURTHY AAO, A/C NO.8336363 AGED ABOUT43YEARS S/O SHRI VENKATAIAH, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O27,DAD HOSTEL ACCOMMODATION, KAGGADASAPURA, C V RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 093 6 9.SHRI SUBHENDU DE AAO/8320323, AGED ABOUT43YEARS S/O SHRI MADHUSUDAN DE, O/O THE PCDA,NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O C-12 ,ALISDA, ALISDA RESI.COMPLEX, R.T. NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 032 PRESENTLY AT: O/O THE CGDA, ULAN BATAR ROAD, DEHLI CANT-110 010 10.SHRI HARIKUMAR MELATH AAO, A/C No.8334222, AGED ABOUT39YEARS, S/O LATE SHRI V GOPALAN ADIYODI, O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE - 560 007 R/O B-1/4, DAD RESI COMPLEX SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE - 560 008. 11.SMT. K B MAYA AAO/8338390 AGED ABOUT40YEARS, D/O SHRI B KRISHNAN NAIR O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE - 560 007 R/O B-5/1, DAD RESI, COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE - 560 008. 7 12.SHRI N SENTHIL KUMAR AAO/8334217 AGED ABOUT47YEARS, S/O LATE SHRI S. NANJE GOWDER, O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE - 560 007 R/O19 1ST MAIN, 2ND CROSS, VIVEK NAGAR, BANGALORE - 560 047. 13.SMT. B SINDHUJA AAO A/C No.8334216 AGED ABOUT40YEARS, W/O SHRI N SENTHIL KUMAR, O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE - 560 007 R/O19 1ST MAIN, 2ND CROSS, VIVEK NAGAR, BANGALORE - 560 047. 14.SHRI D V SUBRAMANYAM AAO A/C No.8325240 AGED ABOUT52YEARS, S/O SHRI D.S.VENKATA SUBBAIAH, PAO(ORs) ASC(AT), BANGALORE R/O4215, 3RD CROSS, 3RD MAIN, JAVARAIAH GARDEN, TYAGARAJA NAGAR, BANGALORE - 560 028 15.SMT. LATHA C N AAO A/C No.8334188 AGED ABOUT42YEARS, W/O SURESH RAMAN KUTTY, PAO(ORs) ASC (AT) BANGALORE8R/O D-19/5, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE - 560 008. PRESENTLY AT O/O AO GE NRC, BUILDING NO.P-51, SF QTRS, ARTY CENTRE, NASIK ROAD CAMP, NASIK - 422 102. 16.SMT. ANUPAMA VERMA AAO A/C No.8320267, AGED ABOUT39YEARS, D/O SHRI RAMESHWAR PD. VERMA PAO(ORs) MLI, BELGAUM - 590 009 R/O12001, MANTRI RESIDENCY, BANNARGHATTA ROAD, BANGALORE - 560 076. PRESENTLY AT PAO (ORS) MEG & C, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE - 560 042. 17.SHRI S CHANDRASEKHAR SAO/ 8325252, AGED ABOUT54YEARS, S/O SHRI R SUBRAMANYAM, O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE - 560 007 R/O D-20/7, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE - 560 008. 18.SMT G. LALITHA AAO, A/C NO,.8334434, AGED ABOTU41YEARS W/O SHRI. SATHYANARAYANAN, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007. R/O B-10/2, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, 9 BANGALORE-8. 19.SHRI. HARIDAS P.K AAO, A/C NO.8334119, AGED ABOUT41YEARS S/O SHRI KRISHNAN P.K. OFFICE OF THE ASTE (AF) YEMALUR POST, BANGALORE-560037 R/O C-16/2, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8. 20.SHRI. BALA SUBRAHAMANIAN AO, A/C NO.8325877, AGED ABOUT50YEARS, S/O NARAYANAN NAIR AO GE, KARWAR-581308 R/O #129, KARTHIKA, IST FLOOR, VELANGINI LINE, GANGAMMA CIRCLE, JALAHALLI EAST, BANGALORE560013. 21.SMT. M. MADHUMATI AO, A/C NO.8325025, AGED ABOTU56YEARS D/O R RAMAMURTHY PAO (ORS)CMP, BANGALORE56002 R/O VILLA L-11, KRISTAL CAMPUS10 YEMERE VILLAGE, DOMMASANDRA POST, SARJAPUR ROAD, BANGALORE-25. 22.SHRI PRABHAKAR H N SO (A), A/C NO.8347132, AGED ABOUT47YEARS S/O T. NAGARAJA PAO (Ors) PARA, BANGALOR-560006 R/O1181 11TH A CROSS, WEST OF CHORD ROAD, 2ND STAGE, MAHALAKSHMIPURAM EXTN, 10 BANGALORE-86. 23.SHRI. V S V ROA SO (A) A/C No.8337141, AGED ABOUT48YEARS S/O LATE V NARASIMHA MURTHY PAO (ORS) MLI BELGAUM-590009 R/O52, DAD QUARTERS, NEAR GANAPATHI TEMPLE HINDALAGA ROAD, BELGAUM-8. 24.SHRI. NN MISHRA SO (A)O, A/C NO.8335924, AGED ABOUT42YEARS S/O SHRI. YOGENDRA MISHRA PAO(ORS) MLI BELGAUM-590009 R/O51, DAD QUARTERS, NEAR GANAPATHI TEMPLE, HINDALAGA ROAD, BELGAUM-8 25.SHRI AVATAPALLI SRINIVAS AO, A/C NO.8336251, AGED ABOUT46YEARS S/O SHRI. VA KRISHNA MURTHY, HQrs. JL WING INFANTRY SCHOOL, BELGAUM-09. R/O FLAT NO.77, 5TH STAGE, HANUMAN NAGAR, DOUBLE ROAD, BELGAUM-01. PRESENTLY AT: AO GE PANAJI, MES BUILDING, S.V. ROAD, PANAJIM-403001. 26.SHRI. RAMESHAN T.T SO, (A), A/C NO.8338658, AGED ABOUT39YEARS S/O K KUNHI KANNAN NAMBIAR, O/O THE IFA COAST GUARD, PB19 PANAMBUR, NEAR MANGALORE-575 010. R/O ALAPPATAMBA11PO-ETTUKUTUKKA VIA-KARIVELLUR DIST-KANNUR KERALA-670521 27.SHRI J JAGANNADHA RAO AAO A/C NO.8335551 AGED ABOUT41YEARS S/O LATE SHRI J RAMA RAO PAO (ORS) MLI BELGAUM-590009 R/O C/O N Y MOREE FLAT NO.75 PRESS COLONY HANUMAN NAGAR BELGAUM-8 28.SMT. MOHANA RUPA AAO, A/C NO.8334219 AGED ABOUT37YEARS W/O SHRI SATHISH GANESAN PAO (ORS) MLI BELGAUM-590009 R/O C-4/6 DAD QUARTERS NEAR GANAPATHI TEMPLE HINDALAGA ROAD BELGAUM-8 29.SHRI R SURESHKUMAR SO(A), A/C NO.8333354 AGED ABOUT46YEARS S/O SHRI K N RAVEENDRAN PILLAI PAO (ORS), ASC (AT), LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O B-15/10, DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX12SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR BANGALORE-8 30.SHRI SAJEEVAN N P SO(A) A/C NO.8338431 AGED ABOUT40YEARS S/O LATE PADMANABHAN O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O NO.6, 9TH MAIN ROAD SULTANPALYA, R T NAGAR BANGALORE-560 032 PRESENTLY AT: O/O THE PAO(ORS) PARA REGT. NEAR MEKHRI CIRCLE BANGALORE-560 006 31.K SANTHOSH KUMAR AAO, A/C NO.8334433 AGED ABOUT50YEARS S/O K K PANICKER O/O PAO ASC SOUTH, LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O B-4/2, DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008 32.SHRI N SHRAVAN KUMAR AAO, A/C NO.8334186 AGED ABOUT43YEARS S/O N VEERAIAH O/O PAO ASC SOUTH, LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O TYPE B-9/9 DAD QUARTERS13SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008 33.SHRI KAJAL KUMAR SAMANTA SO (A), A/C NO.8334713 AGED ABOUT43YEARS S/O A K SAMANTA O/O PAO ASC SOUTH, LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O QTR. NO.B-15/1, DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008 34.SHRI A SURESH` SO (A) A/C NO.8338437 AGED ABOUT52YEARS S/O S ACHUTHANARAYANAN O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560 007 R/O TYPE C-17/27 DAD QUARTERS SOMESHWARAPURA ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008 35.B DIVYA AAO A/C NO.8336466 AGED ABOUT42YEARS D/O R BABU O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST14BANGALORE-560 007 R/O NO.33 II MAIN SECTOR A-1 BANJARA ORCHIDS HORAMAVU BANGALORE-560 043 36.SHRI RAVI KUMR AAO A/C NO.8325502 AGED ABOUT53YEARS, S/O LATE M ESHWARA AO O/O PAI ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O NO.128, 5TH CROSS, NRUPATHUNGA EXTEN R.T.NAGAR POST, BANGALORE-560 032 37.SRI ANANTA MARIDAYYA AAO A/C NO.8336556 AGED ABOUT40YEARS, S/O VENKATA SATYANARAYANA O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O TYPE B-10/4, DAD QUARTERS, SOMESWARAPURA ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008 38.SHRI RAJASEKAR R AAO A/C NO.8333445 AGED ABOUT43YEARS, S/O S RAMAMOORTHY15O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O1712 DAD QUARTERS, SOMESWARAPURA ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008 39.SHRI RAJENDRAN U AAO A/C NO.8334181 AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O LATE ULPALAKSHAN O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O4H, 4TH D CROSS, EJIPURA BANGALORE-560 047 PRESENTLY AT IFA COMCG (ANC) COAST GUARD REGION (A&N), P.B.NO.716 HADDO PO PORT BLAIR-744102 40.S. VEERALAKSHMI AAO A/C NO.8336400 AGED ABOUT40YEARS, D/O S SANKARAN O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O TYPE B515 DAD QUARTERS SOMESWARAPURA ULSOOR BANGALORE-560008 16 PRESENTLY AT OFFICE OF THE IFA26D, HAL, VIMANAPRUA POST BANGALORE-560017 41.H R SHAILAJA AAO A/C NO.8327171 AGED ABOUT49YEARS, W/O N KRISHNA PRASAD PAO (ORS) MLI, BELGAUM-590009 R/O NO.32, 4TH TEMPLE ROAD, 15TH CROSS MALLESWARAM BANGALORE-560003 PRESENT AT O/O THE CDA (R & D) C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93 42.SHRI DAWOOD SHAIKH AAO A/C NO.8329137 AGED ABOUT48YEARS, S/O SAIFFUDDIN N SHAIKH O/O THE PAO (ORS)MLI BELGAUM-590009 R/O H NO.64, HIGH STREET CAMP BELGAON-590 001 43.SHRI SUNIL S AAO A/C NO.8331997 AGED ABOUT43YEARS, S/O K SIVARAMAN17O/O THE PAO (ORS)MLI BELGAUM-590009 R/O FIRST FLOOR F-03 VARADA RESIDENCY, BUDA SCHEME51 TEKADI NEAR TAKAT BUILDING, BELGAUM44SHRI SREENIVASA AAO A/C NO.8334344 AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O SHANKAR BHAT O/O THE PAO (ORS)MLI BELGAUM-590009 R/O NO.C-6/6 DAD QUARTERS, LIKHA NAGAR HANUMAN NAGAR BELGAUM-590019 45.SHRI T.SIVA PRASAD AAO A/C NO.8336283 AGED ABOUT38YEARS, S/O T VARADHA RAJU O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O Q NO.01/03, DAD HOSTEL, C V RAMANNAGAR KHAGADASAPURA1T CROSS BANGALORE-560093 46.SHRI M G DIWAKAR SAO A/C NO.8325255 AGED ABOUT50YEARS, S/O MSG SUBRAMANIAM18O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O NO.427, 6TH MAIN ROAD A BLOCK, RAJAJINAGAR2D STAGE BANGALORE-55 PRESENTLY AT AO (NAVY) C/O INHS PATHANJALI NAVAL BASE, KARWAR-581308 47.REKHA VIJAYARAGHAVAN AO A/C NO.8334172 AGED ABOUT43YEARS, D/O K.SUBBA RAO O/O PCDA LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O NO.1A006 KRISHNA IKON APARTMENTS, ANNASANDRA PALYA HAL PO BANGALORE-560 017 48.SHRI ANANT NARAYAN DASH SO (A) A/C NO.8336644 AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O LATE SURENDRAMOHAN DASH O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAMPOST BANGALORE-560007 R/O Q.NO.B-4/14, DAD QUARTERS, SOMESWARAPURA ULSOOR19BANGALORE-560008 49.SHRI A ARUL ALIAS AGASTHIAN SO (A) A/C NO.8338402 AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O LATE R.ARUMUGAM O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O #8/7, DAD QUARTERS, SOMESWARAPURA ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008 50.V MEENATCHI AAO A/C NO.8334377 AGED ABOUT40YEARS, D/O K.VENKATESWARAN O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O F4/2, VIJAY KIRAN APARTMENTS VICTORIA ROAD VICTORIA LAYOUT BANGLAORE-560 047 51.SHRI S SHUNMUGANNATHAN SO (A), A/C NO.8338396 AGED ABOUT44YEARS, S/O A SUDALAI MUTHU O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O #1/3, DAD QUARTERS, SOMESWARAPURA ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008 PRESENTLY AT O/O THE RAO MES NO.99, 20 DICKENSON ROAD BANGALORE-560 042 52.SHRI JAGADISH KUMAR C.K. SO (A), A/C NO.8337337 AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O CHANDRASHEKARA PANICKER O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O #11/2 DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX, SOMESWARAPURA ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008 53.SHRI S ARUMUGAM SO (A), A/C NO.8338397 AGED ABOUT45YEARS S/O LATE S.S.RAGHAVAN PILLAI, O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O C-17/19, DAD QUARTERS, SOMESWARAPURA ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008 54.SMT. V BHUVANESWARI AAO A/C NO.8327144 AGED ABOUT50YEARS, W/O N VENKATACHALAM O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O MATHURA D-2 BLOCK V, ANNANSANDRA PALYA MAL PO BANGALORE-560017 55.SMT. SEEMA.K.B. SO (A) 21 A/C NO.8337233 AGED ABOUT42YEARS, D/O K.M.BABU O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O141 DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX, SOMESWARAPURA ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008 56.SMT. MAYA ARUN AAO A/C NO.8334432 AGED ABOUT37YEARS W/O B. ARUN O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560093 R/O #106, FALCON NEST APARTMENTS, 1ST A CROSS KAGGADASAPURA C.V.RAMAN NAGAR BANGALORE-93 57.SHRI TVS RAMA KRISHNA AAO A/C NO.8337294 AGED ABOUT41YEARS S/O T V S CHALAPATHI RAO O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560093 R/O SH17, DRDO PHASE1, C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93 58.S NAGABHUSHAN REDDY AAO A/C NO.8332461 AGED ABOUT50YEARS S/O LATE S THIPPA REDDY O/O THE CDA (R &D), C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, 22 BANGALORE-560093 R/O C-13/8, DRDO TOWNSHIP PHASE-I C.V.RAMAN NAGAR BANGALORE-93 59.SHRI RAJESH WILLIAMS S/O (A) A/C NO.8339962 AGED ABOUT41YEARS, S/O WILLIAMS MASCREEN O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93 R/O B-9/10 DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT ULSOOR BANGALORE-8 60.SHRI SIMANCHAN MOHAPATRO AAO A/C NO.8338804 AGED ABOUT55YEARS S/O BANCHANIDI MOHAPATRO O/O THE CDA RTC (SR), DRDO TOWNSHIP PHASE-1 C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560093 R/O C-4/13, DRDO TOWNSHIP PHASE-I C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93 61.SHRI VENUGOPAL M AAO A/C NO.8333401 AGED ABOUT44YEARS S/O MAHALINGE GOWDA O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V.RAMAN NAGAR BANGALORE23R/O C-39/12 DRDO TOWNSHIP PHASE-II, KAGGADASAPURA BANGALORE-93 62.SHRI J.V.SUBBA RAO AAO A/C N.8336341 AGED ABOUT43YEARS, S/ LATE SHRI J RADHA KRISHNA MURTHY O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560093 R/O B-13/06, DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT ULSOOR BANGALORE-8 63.SHRI JOSEPH THOMAS CHIRACKAL SAO A/C NO.8331564 AGED ABOUT49YEARS, S/O LATE SHRI C J THOMAS O/O THE CDA (R&D) CV RAMAN NAGAR BANGALORE-93 R/O B-14/7, DAD RESI. COMPLEX SOMESHWARAPURA ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8 64.SHRI T A SRINIVASA AAO, A/C NO.8334442, AGED ABOUT45YEARS, S/O SHRI C ANJANEYA, O.O THE AO(R&D), DFRL, SIDDARTHA NAGAR, MYSORE-11, R/O QTR, NO.7, TYPE-III, DFRL QUARTERS, SIDDARTHA NAGAR, MYSORE-11 24 65.SHRI C K BALAKRISHNAN AAO, A/C NO.8337364, AGED ABOUT47YEARS, S/O SHRI KUNHIKANNAN A P O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560093 R/O23, DAD HOSTEL ACCOMMODATION, KAGADASAPURA, C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93 66.SMT ANITA K N AAO, A/C NO.8334451, AGED ABOUT41YEARS, W/O SHRI P MANOJ KUMAR, O/O THE CDA(R&D), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560093 R/O NO.72, GURU REDDY LAYOUT, AKASH NAGAR, B NARAYANA PURA, K.R.PURAM, BANGALORE-16 67.SMT RUCHIKA PRIYADARSHI SO(A), A/C NO.8335895, AGED ABOUT41YEARS, W/O SHRI ABHINAV PRIYADARSHI, O/O THE CDA(R&D), C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560093 R/O FLAT NO.6 D I, KRISHNA NAGAR APARTMENTS, AANASANDRA PALYA, HAL, VIMANAPURA POST, BANGALORE-17 68.SHRI T SARAVANAN AAO, A/C NO.8334240, AGED ABOUT39YEARS, S/O SHRI S K TAMIL MANI, O/O THE CDA(R&D), C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560093 25 R/O NO.C-45/2, DRDO TOWNSHIP, PHASE-II, KAGGADASAPURA, BANGALORE-93 69.SHRI A LOURDES THEODRE AO, A/C NO.8325588, AGED ABOUT52YEARS, S/O J ARULDOSS, O/O THE CDA(R&D), C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560093 PRESENTLY AT: IFA WNC, MUMBAI, 3RD FLOOR, NOORBHAI BUILDING, (HQ MAGNA BUILDING), SHAHEED BHAAT SINGH MARG, MUMBAI-400023 70.SHRI D R KARIM AAO, A/C NO.8334214, AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O SHRI RASUL, O/O THE CDA(R&D), C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93 R/O NO.C-38/10, DRDO TOWNSHIP, PHASE-II, KAGGADASAPURA, BANGALORE-93 71.SHRI V N HARIHARAN AAO,A/C NO.8334231, AGED ABOUT50YEARS, S/O V.V.NARAYANA SWAMY, O/O THE CDA(R&D), C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560093 R/O FLAT NO.003, MATHRU SREE SILVER HOMES, 4TH CROSS, ABBAIAH REDDY LAYOUT, KAGGADASAPURA, BANGALORE-93 26 72.SHRI MAHENDRA KUMAR L S AAO, A/C NO.8334194, AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O SHRI SHIVAMURTHAPPA L M O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE93R/O NO.C-39/6, DRDO TOWNSHIP, PHASE-II, KAGGADASAPURA, BANGALORE9373.SHRI S SRINATH SAO, A/C NO.8332541, AGED ABOUT49YEARS, S/O M SAMPATH KUMAR O/O THE CDA (R&D), C V RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE93R/O NO.D.NO.1G, 15TH STREET HALASURU, BANGALORE-8 74.SHRI AJAI KUMAR M AAO, A/C NO.8332686, AGED ABOUT46YEARS, S/O SHRI MANIKANTAN NAIR K O/O THE CDA (R&D), C V RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93 R/O NO.C-17/11, DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX, CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT, ULSOOR, BANGALORE875.SHRI MK RAGHUNATH AAO A/C NO.8334196 AGED ABOUT48YEARS, S/O LATE GOVINDAN NAIR O/O THE PAO (ORS) MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE56004 R/O NO.65, 7TH CROSS, NR GANESH TEMPLE, BYAPPANAHALLI INDIRANAGAR POST, BANGALORE56003 27 76.SMT B CHITRA AAO A/C NO.8338429, AGED ABOUT37YEARS, W/O G MAHESH O/O THE PAO (ORS)MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE56004 R/O FLAT NO.G3, SRI RANGA APTS NO.22 CAR STREET, HALASURU, BANGALORE56000 77.SHRI R SREEKUMAR SO (A) A/C NO.8339260, AGED ABOUT55YEARS, S/O LATE K RAGHAVAN NAIR O/O THE PAO (ORS) MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE56004 R/O NO.B2/8, DAD RESIDENTIAL QTRS, SOMESWARAPURA EXTN CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT, ULSOOR, BANGALORE56000 78.SHRI CP ANILKUMAR SAO A/C NO8325382, AGED ABOUT54YEARS, S/O SHRI N P NARAYANAN O/O THE PAO (ORS) MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE56004 R/O D-19/3, DAD QTRS, CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT, SOMESWARAPURA EXTENTION, ULSOOR, BANGALORE56000 79.SMT B SHANTI SRI AO A/C NO.8332017, AGED ABOUT43YEARS, W/O N VIJAYA BHASKAR O/O PAO (Ors) MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE56004 R/O NO.304, GAUTHAM APARTMENTS, PLOT332 I CROSS, V MAIN JAGDEESH NAGAR, BANGALORE2880.SHRI E RAVICHANDER AAO A/C NO.8334386 AGED ABOUT50YEARS, S/O LATE T ELUMALAI O/O THE PAO (ORS) MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE56004 R/O NO.17/1, OSBORNE ROAD CROSS, BANGALORE4281.SMT ARUNA SUDHA PARIMALA AAO A/C NO.8336504 AGED ABOUT38YEARS W/O P AJAY KUMAR O/O THE PAO(ORS) MEG & CENTRE OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE-560042 R/O NO.B-6/9, DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX SOMESHWARA EXTN, CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT BANGALORE-560008 82.SMT H KUSUMA AAO A/C NO.8336498 AGED ABOUT43YEARS W/O H V NARAYANA RAO O/O THE PAO(ORS) MEG & CENTRE OLD MADRAS ROAD BANGALORE-560042 R/O C-17/6, DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX SOMESWARA EXTN, CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT BANGALORE-560008 83.SMT REJITHA P S AAO, A/C NO.8337365 AGED ABOUT40YEARS D/O PN SREEDHARAN O/O THE PAO(ORS) PARA, BANGALORE-560006 R/O NO.301, 3RD FLOOR, 29 SUNDHER MANOR, NP FACTORY ROAD KAVALBYRASANDRA RT NAGAR POST BANGALORE84SMT N PREMA AA0, A/C NO.8329054 AGED ABOUT48YEARS D/O LATE G NATARAJAN O/O THE PAO(ORS) PARA, BANGALORE-560006 R/O NO.10/1, 5TH CROSS GOPALAPPA LAYOUT MANORANJANA PALYA, RT NAGAR BANGALORE PRESENTLY AT O/O AO GE(I) R & D (EAST/WEST) C V RAMAN NAGAR BANGALORE-560093 85.SMT SIVAPRIYA KARTHIK AO, A/C NO.8334387 AGED ABOUT38YEARS W/O SHRI R KARTHIK O/O THE PAO(ORS) MEG & CENTRE OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE-560042 R/O NO.D-19/7, DAD RESI COMPLEX SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR BANGALORE-8 86.SMT SENTHA SRINIVASAN SAO A/C NO.8325305 AGED ABOUT54YEARS W/O A SRINIVASAN O/O THE PAO(ORS) MEG & CENTRE OLD MADRAS ROAD BANGALORE-560042 30 R/O NO.8, 2ND CORSS, VINAYAKA LAYOUT HORAMAVU, BANGALORE-560043 PRESENTLY AT: O/O AO GE AF HEBBAL BANGALORE-560006 87.SMT MALATHI DAYAN AAO A/C NO.8336463 W/O MOSES DAYAN AGED ABOUT41YEARS O/O THE PAO(ORS) MEG & CENTRE OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE-560042 R/O NO.18/2, 2ND LANE, 2ND CROSS KANAKADASA LAYOUT LINGARAJAPURA, BANGALORE88SMT J MAHALAKSHMI AAO A/C NO.8337352 AGED ABOUT43YEARS W/O SHRI MAKENDRAN P O/O THE PAO(ORS) MEG & CENTRE OLD MADRAS ROAD BANGALORE-560042 R/O NO.4/24, IST CROSS, IST MAIN LINGARAJAPURA BANGALORE-560084 89.SHRI C SREENIVASAMURTHY AAO, A/C NO.8325428 AGED ABOUT51YEARS S/O LATE CHINNAIAH O/O THE PAO(ORS) MEG & CENTRE OLD MADRAS ROAD BANGALORE-560042 31 R/O NO.20/2, PETTIGREW STREET BHARATHINAGAR BANGALORE-560001 90.SHRI. SATHEESHKUMAR V AAO, A/C No.8334402, AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O. SHRI. A. VELAPPAN PILLAI, O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000, R/O. Q.No.2/5, DAD HOSTEL ACCOMMODATION, KAGGADASAPURA MAIN ROAD, C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE9391.SHRI. S G SRIKUMAR AAO, A/C No.8334083, AGED ABOUT45YEARS, S/O. SHRI.K. SIVASANKARAN NAIR, O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000, R/O. No.C-18/2, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE892.SHRI. GIRISHKUMAR V G AAO, A/C NO.8334390, AGED ABOUT38YEARS, S/O. SHRI.V.P. GOPALAKRISHNAN NAIR, O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000, R/O. No.C-18/8, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, 32 ULSOOR, BANGALORE893.SHRI. M. BALASUBARAMANIAN AAO, A/C No.8338438, AGED ABOUT43YEARS, S/O. SHRI.E MANTHIRAN, O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000, R/O. No.2644, 3RD CROSS, 18TH MAIN, HAL STAGE II, BANGALORE94SHRI. MADHU SUDHAN AAO, A/C No.8336299, AGED ABOUT37YEARS, S/O. SHRI.GOPAL SWAMY, O/O THE PAO (ORS) PCTC, No.99, DICKENSON ROAD, BANGALORE42 R/O. B-1/6, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE8 PRESENTLY AT, O/O. RAO MES, No.99, DICKENSON ROAD, BANGALORE56004 95.SHRI. K. SUNILKUMAR SAO, A/C No.8334184, AGED ABOUT43YEARS, S/O. SHRI.A. KARUNAKARAN, O/O THE PAO (ORS) PCTC, No.99, DICKENSON ROAD, BANGALORE42 R/O. No.3460, 13TH-A-MAIN, HAL2D STAGE, INDIRANAGAR, BANGALORE -8 96.SHRI. D V NAGARAJ AAO, A/C No.8327027, AGED ABOUT56YEARS, 33 S/O. SHRI.VENKATARAMANAPPA, O/O THE PAO (ORS) PCTC, No.99, DICKENSON ROAD, BANGALORE42 R/O. No.18, 9TH CROSS, MUNINANJAPPA LAYOUT, RAMAMUARTHY NAGAR, BANGALORE1697.SMT. SRILAKSHMI AAO, A/C No.8336458, AGED ABOUT45YEARS, W/O. SHRI. V. SUBRAHMANYAM, OFFICE OF THE DPDO, (UNDER CDA, CHENNAI), DICKENSON ROAD, BENGALURU42 R/O. C-12/9, DRDO TOWN SHIP, PHASE-I, C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BENGALURU93 98.SHRI. G. VENKATA KRISHNA AAO, A/C No.8336289, AGED ABOUT38YEARS, S/O. PULLESWARA RAO. O/O. THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000, R/O. C-18/6, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE0899.SHRI R SURESH MAHENDRA AAO, A/C NO.8325648, AGED ABOUT49YEARS, S/O SHRI C RAJANNA, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007. R/O NO.68, RHCS LAYOUT, SRIGANDHA KAVAL, NAGARBHAVI, BANGALORE-94. 34 100.SHRI RAMA MUTHANANITHA PERUMAL AAO, A/O NO.8332754, AGED ABOUT38YEARS, S/O SHRI RAMA SUBRAMANIAN, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007. R/O C-17/3, DAD RESI COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR BANGALORE-8. 101.SHRI TOM JOSEPH AAO, A/C NO.8333449, AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O SHRI JOHN JOSEPH, O/O THE DCDA (DAD) HAL, BANGALORE COMPLEX, VIMANAPURA POST, BANGALORE-17, R/O C-18/24, DAD RESI COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8. 102.SHRI T SHREEHARI AAO, A/C NO.8336531, AGED ABOUT38YEARS, S/O SHRI T SUBBRAYUDU, O/O THE DCDA(DAD) HAL, BANGALORE COMPLEX, VIMANPURA POST, BANGALORE-17, R/O C-16/11, DAD RESI, COMPLEX, SOMESHWRAPURA ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8 103.SHRI P SANKAR SO(A), A/C NO.8338410, AGED ABOUT51YEARS, S/O SHRI.T.S.PARAMASIVAN, PAO (ORS) MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE-560042. R/O C-18/19, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA ULSOOR BANGALORE-8. 35 104.SHRI A N V RAMANJANEYULU SO(A) A/C NO.8345590, AGED ABOUT32YEARS, S/O SHRI A.PULLESWARA RAO, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007. R/O B-14/2, DAD RESI COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR BANGALORE-8. 105.SHRI H B DAKSHINA MURTHY SO(A), A/C NO.8338414, AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O SHRI BASAVARAJAIAH, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007, R/O NO.3353, 6TH MAIN, 3RD CROSS, RPC LAYOUT, VIJAYANAGAR, BANGALORE-40 106.SMT L SREE KUMARI AAO, A/C NO.8325645, AGED ABOUT50YEARS, W/O K.RAMARAJAN, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007. R/O411B, VIGNESH NIVAS, 8TH CROSS, VIGNANA NAGAR, NEW THIPPASANDRA, BANGALORE-75, PRESENTLY AT: O/O THE PAO (ORS) ASC (AT) AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007. 107.SMT V KAVITHA SAO, A/C NO.8332533, AGED ABOUT45YEARS, W/O SHRI M.N.VIJAYA KUMAR, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007, R/O NO.8, 6TH MAIN, CHIKKAADUGODI, 36 D.R.COLLEGE POST, BANGALORE-560029. PRESENTLY AT: O/O THE AO GE (AF), YELAHANKA, BANGALORE-560063. 108.SMT. M. CHITTI SNEHALATHA AAO, A/C NO.8332367, AGED ABOUT49YEARS, W/O SHRI SESHU BABU P O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O NO.108, SRI SAPTAGIRI MEDOWS, OGANHALLI ROAD, PANATHUR, BANGALORE-103 109.SMT. VISHNUPRIYA VENKATAKRISHANAN SAO A/C No.8333947, AGED ABOUT39YEARS, D/O LATE SRI. VENKATA VARADAN O/O THE CDA (R AND D), C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560093 R/O C-24/12, C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93 PRESENTLY AT O/O THE CDA, NO.618, ANNASALAI, TEYNAMPET, CHENNAI-600018 110.SRI. T. THENNARASU AAO A/C No.8331994, AGED ABOUT44YEARS, S/O LATE ELA.THAMIL SELVAN O/O THE LAO (AF), JALAHALLI (WEST), 37 BANGALORE-15 R/O C-18/14, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8 111.SHRI. S. SHASI KUMAR SO (A) A/C NO.8339174 AGED ABOUT40YEARS, S/O SHRI. VENKATA MALLAIAH, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD AND POST, BANGALORE-560007 R/O B-12/10, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-08 112.SHRI. P. RAVI KANTH SO(A) A/C NO.8339210 AGED ABOUT39YEARS, S/O P. SRINIVASA RAO O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD AND POST, BANGALORE-560007 R/O B-8/13, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-08 113.SHRI. S. BADARI NARAYANA SO(A) A/C NO.8339204 AGED ABOUT39YEARS, S/O SHRI. SUBBA RAO O/O THE PAO (ORS) CMP, NELLASANDRA, BANGALORE-560025 R/O B-5/10, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-08 38 114.SMT. LEENA LASKAR SO(A) A/C NO.8336958 AGED ABOUT38YEARS, W/O SHRI DEBOJYOTI LASKAR O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O Q.NO.2/8, DAD HOSTEL TYPE ACCOMMODATION, 1ST A MAIN CROSS, KAGGADASAPURA MAIN ROAD, C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93 115.SMT. A. JAYA BHARATHI SAO A/C NO.8333460, AGED ABOUT42YEARS W/O SHRI. ANANDA DASS, O/O THE AO GE (NORTH) MEANEE LINES, MEG AND CENTRE, BANGALORE-42 R/O NO.490, 2ND FLOOR, 6TH D CROSS, 6TH BLOCK, KORAMANGALA, BANGALORE116SMT. BARKHA RANI AAO, A/C NO.8337377, AGED ABOUT38YEARS, W/O RAMESH PRASAD, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007 R/O B-4/3, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8 ... RESPONDENTS (BY SRI ONKARA K B, ADVOCATE FOR C/R1-R24 28, R30-34, R36-48, R50, R52-68, R70-72, R74-75, R78, R80-87, R90, R92-102, R104-108, R111-115) 39 THESE PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLES226AND227OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE

ORDER

DATED2108.2015 PASSED IN O.A.NO.170/01056 TO11712015 PASSED BY THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, BANGALORE BENCH BANGALORE VIDE ANNEXURE-A TO THE W.P. AND ETC. IN W.P.NO.53273/2016 & W.P.NOS.54819-54917/2016 BETWEEN1SHRI N SRINIVASALU AAO, A/C NO.8336500 AGED ABOUT40YEARS, S/O SHRI N.SUBBARAYUDU, O/O THE PCDA NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-7 R/O C-15/9, DAD RESI, COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008. 2.N.CHANDRASEKAR AAO, A/C NO.8317424, AGED ABOUT57YEARS, S/O LATE G.M.NARAYANA REDDY, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007. R/O NO.24, 3RD CROSS, 2ND MAIN, BALAJI NAGAR, DHARMARAM COLLEGE POST, BANGALORE-29. 40 3.SHRI R.RAVINDRA BABU AAO, A/C NO.8334218 AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O SHRI RC VEERANNA, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O B-2/6, DAD RESI.COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008. 4.SHRI U SURENDRA PAI AAO/8336637, AGED ABOUT50YEARS, S/O SHRI U.SITARAM PAI, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O G-4, A BLOCK, SRIVEN SPLENDOUR, CHALLAGHATTA, BANGALORE-560 037. 5.SHRI K.V.SRINIVASA RAO AAO/8336267 AGED ABOUT51YEARS, S/O SHRI K.V.N. RAO O/O PAO (ORS) ASC (AT), LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007, R/O C-17/21, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008. 6.SHRI P.L.SRINIVAS AAO/8336292, AGED ABOUT40YEARS, S/O SHRI P V L N RAO, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O B-1/15, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, 41 BANGALORE-560 008. 7.SHRI C.V.SUDHAKARA REDDY AAO, A/C NO.8334420, AGED ABOUT41YEARS, S/O C.V.SUBBA REDDY, O/O THE PCDA NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O B-3/2, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008. 8.SHRI K.VISHNU MURTY AAO, A/C NO.8336363 AGED ABOUT43YEARS, S/O SHRI VENKATAIAH, O/O THE PCDA NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O27, DAD HOSTEL ACCOMMODATION, KAGGADASAPURA, C V RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 093. 9.SHRI SUBHENDU DE AAO/8320323 AGED ABOUT43YEARS S/O SHRI MADHUSUDAN DE O/O THE PCDA, NO.107 LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007 R/O C-12, ALISDA, ALISDA RESI COMPLEX, R T NAGAR BANGALORE-560032 PRESENTLY WORKING AT O/O THE CGDA, ULAN BATAR ROAD, DELHI CANT-110010 10.SHRI HARIKUMAR MELATH AAO, A/C NO.8334222 42 AGED ABOUT39YEARS S/O LATE SHRI V GOPALAN ADIYODI O/O THE PCDA, NO.107 LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O B-1/4, DAD RESI COMPLEX SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560008 11.SMT K B MAYA AAO/8338390 AGED ABOUT40YEARS D/O SHRI B KRISHNAN NAIR O/8O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007 R/O B-5/1, DAD RESI COMPLEX SOMESHWARAPURA ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560008 12.SHRI N SENTHIL KUMAR AAO, A/C NO.8334217 AGED ABOUT47YEARS S/O LATE SHRI S NANJE GOWDER O/O THE PCDA, NO.107 LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007 R/O19 IST MAIN, 2ND CROSS VIVEK NAGAR BANGALORE-560047 13.SMT B SINDHUJA AAO, A/C NO.8334216 AGED ABOUT40YEARS W/O SHRI N SENTHIL KUMAR O/O THE PCDA, NO.107 LOWER AGRAM ROAD43AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560007 R/O19 1ST MAIN, 2ND CROSS VIVEK NAGAR BANGALORE-560047 14.SHRI D V SUBRAMANYAM AAO,A/C NO.8325240 AGED ABOUT52YEARS S/O SHRI D S VENKATA SUBBAIAH PAO(ORS) ASC(AT) BANGALORE R/O4215, 3RD CROSS, 3RD MAIN JAVARAIAH GARDEN TYAGARAJA NAGAR BANGALORE-560028 15.SMT LATHA C N AAO, A/C NO.8334188 AGED ABOUT42YEARS W/O SURESH RAMAN KUTTY PAO(ORS)ASC(AT)BANGALORE R/O D-19/5 DAD RESI COMPLEX SOMESWARAPURA ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560008 PRESENTLY W/A O/AO GE NRC BUILDING NO.P-51 SF-QTRS ARTY CENTRE NASIK ROAD CAMP, NASIK-422102 16.SMT ANUPAMA VERMA AAO, A/C NO.8320267 AGED ABOUT39YEARS D/O SHRI RAMESHWAR PD. VERMA PAO(ORS) MLI, BELGAUM44R/O12001, MANTRI RESIDENCY BANNERGHATTA ROAD, BANGALORE-560076 PRESENTLY WORKING AT PAO(ORS)MEG & C OLD MADRAS ROAD BANGALORE-560042 17.SHRI S CHANDRASEKHAR SAO/8325252, AGED ABOUT54YEARS, S/O SHRI R SUBRAMANYAM O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000 R/O D-20/7,DAD RESI COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR BANGALORE56000 18.SMT G LALITHA AAO,A/C NO.8334434, AGED ABOUT41YEARS, W/O SHRI S SATHYANARAYANAN, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000 R/O B-10/2, DAD RESI COMPLEX SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8 19.SHRI HARIDAS P K AAO, A/C NO.8334119 AGED ABOUT41YEARS, S/O SHRI KRISHNAN P K OFFICE OF THE ASTE (AF), YEMALUR POST, BANGALORE56003 R/O C-16/2, DAD RESI COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE845 20.SMT M MADHUMATI AO A/C NO.8325025 AGED ABOUT56YEARS, D/O R RAMAMURTHY PAO (ORS) CMP, BANGALORE R/O VILLA L-11, KRISTAL CAMPUS10 YEMERE VILLAGE, DOMMASANDRA POST, SARJAPURA ROAD, BANGALORE2521.SHRI PRABHAKAR H N SO(A), A/C NO.8347132, AGED ABOUT47YEARS, S/O T NAGARAJ PAO (ORS) PARA, BANGALORE R/O1181 11TH ‘A’ CROSS, WEST OF CHORD ROAD, 2ND STAGE, MAHALAKSHMIPURAM EXTN., BANGALORE8622.SHRI NN MISHRA SO (A), A/C NO.8335924 AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O SHRI YOGENDRA MISHRA PAO (ORS) MLI BELGAUM R/O51, DAD QUARTERS, NEAR GANAPATHI TEMPLE HINDALAGA ROAD, BELGAUM823.SMT MOHAN RUPA AAO, A/C NO.8334219, AGED ABOUT37YEARS, W/O SHRI SATHISH GANESAN PAO (ORS) MLI BELGAUM R/O C-4/6, DAD QUARTERS, NEAR GANAPATHI TEMPLE HINDALAGA ROAD BELGAUM846 24.SHRI R SURESHKUMAR SO(A), A/C NO.8333354, AGED ABOUT46YEARS, S/O SHRI K N RAVEENDRAN PILLAI PAO (ORS) ASC(AT), LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000 R/O B-15/10, RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8 25.SHRI SAJEEVAN N P SO(A), A/C NO.8338431, AGED ABOUT40YEARS, S/O LATE PADMANABHAN, O/O PAO ASC SOUTH, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007, R/O NO.6, 9TH MAIN ROAD, SULTANPALYA, RT NAGAR, BANGALORE-560032. PRESENTLY WORKING AT: O/O THE PAO (ORS) PARA REGT. NEAR MEKHRI CIRCLE, BANGALORE-560006. 26.K SANTHOSH KUMAR AAO A/C No.8334433, AGED ABOUT50YEARS, S/O KK PANICKER, O/O PAO ASC SOUTH, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGLAORE-560007. R/O B-4/2, DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560008. 27.SHRI N SHRAVAN KUMAR AAO, A/C NO.8334186, AGED ABOUT43YEARS, S/O N VEERAIAH, O/O PAO ASC SOUTH, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007 R/O TYPE B-9/9 DAD QUARTERS, SOMESHWARAPURA ULSOOR, 47 BANGALORE-560008. 28.SHRI KAJAL KUMAR SAMANTA SO(A), A/C NO.8334713, AGED ABOUT43YEARS, S/O A.K.SAMANTA, O/O PAO ASC SOUTH, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007. R/O QTR.NO.-B-15/1, DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560008. 29.B DIVYA AAO, A/C NO.8336466, AGED ABOUT42YEARS, D/O R.BABU, O/O PAO ASC SOUTH, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007. R/O NO.33, II MAIN, SECTOR A-1, BANJARA ORCHIDS, HORAMAVU, BANGALORE-560043. 30.SHRI ANANTA MARIDAYYA AAO, A/C NO.8336556, AGED ABOUT40YEARS, S/O VENKATA SATYANARAYANA, O/O PAO ASC SOUTH, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007. R/O TYPE B-10/14, DAD QUARTERS, SOMESWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560008. 31.SHRI RAJASEKAR R AAO, A/C NO.8333445, AGED ABOUT43YEARS, S/O S RAMAMOORTHY, O/O PAO ASC SOUTH, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007. R/O1712, DAD QUARTERS, SOMESWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560008 48 32.SHRI RAJENDRAN U AAO, A/C NO.8334181, AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O LATE ULPALAKSHAN, O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007 R/O4H, 4TH D CROSS, EJIPURA, BANGALORE-560047. PRESENTLY WORKING AT: IFA COMCG(ANC), COAST GUARD REGION (A&N), P.B.NO.716, HADDO PO, PORT BLAIR-744102. 33.S VEERALAKSHMI AAO,A/C NO.8336400, AGED ABOUT40YEARS D/O S SANKARAN, O/O PAO ASC SOUTH, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST,BANGALORE-560 007 R/O TYPE B515 DAD QUARTERS, SOMESWARAPURA,ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008 PRESENTLY WORKING AT:OFFICE OF THE IFA26D, HAL,VIMANAPURA POST, BANGALORE-560 017 34.H R SHAILAJA AAO,A/C NO.8327171 AGED ABOUT49YEARS W/O N KRISHNA PRASAD, PAO(ORS)MLI,BELGAUM-590 009 R/O NO.32,4TH TEMPLE ROAD, 15TH CROSS, MALLESWARAM, BANGALORE-560 003 PRESENTLY WORKING AT:O/O THE CDA (R & D) C V RAMAN NAGAR, 49 BANGALORE-93 35.SHRI SUNIL S AAO,A/C NO.8331997 AGED ABOUT43YEARS S/O K SIVARAMAN, O/O THE PAO (ORS)MLI,BELGAUM-590 009 R/O FIRST FLOOR,F-03, VARADA RESIDENCY, BUDA SCHEME51TEKADI, NEAR TAKAT BUILDING, BELGAUM36SHRI S SREENIVASA AAO,A/C NO.8334344, AGED ABOUT42YEARS S/O SHANKAR BHAT, O/O THE PAO(ORS)MLI, BELGAUM-590 009 R/O NO.C-6/6,DAD QUARTERS, LEKHA NAGAR,HANUMAN NAGAR, BELGAUM-590 019 37.SHRI T SIVA PRASAD AAO,A/C NO.8336283, AGED ABOUT38YEARS S/O T VARADHA RAJU, O/O PAO ASC SOUTH, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 R/O Q.NO.01/03,DAD HOSTEL, C V RAMANAGAR, KHAGADASAPURA1T CROSS, BANGALORE-560 093 50 38.SHRI M G DIWAKAR SAO,A/C NO.8325255, AGED ABOUT50YEARS S/O MSG SUBRAMANIAM O/O PAO ASC SOUTH, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST,BANGALORE-560 007 R/O NO.427,6TH MAIN ROAD, A BLOCK,RAJAJI NAGAR, 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE-55 PRESENTLY WORKING AT:AO (NAVY) C/O INHS PATHANJALI, NAVAL BASE,KARWAR-581 308 39.REKHA VIJAYARAGHAVAN AO, A/C NO.8334172, AGED ABOUT43YEARS D/O K SUBBA RAO, O/O PCDA,LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST,BANGALORE-560 007 R/O NO.1A006,KRISHNA IKON APARTMENTS, ANNASANDRA PALYA, HAL PO,BANGALORE-560 017 40.SHRI ANANTA NARAYAN DASH SO(A),A/C NO.8336644, AGED ABOUT42YEARS S/O LATE SURENDRA MOHAN DASH, O/O PAO ASC SOUTH,LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAMPOST,BANGALORE-560 007 R/O Q.NO.B-4/14,DAD QUARTERS, SOMESHWARPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008 51 41.V MEENATCHI AAO, A/C NO.8334377 AGED ABOUT40YEARS D/O K VENKATESWARAN O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560 007 R/O#F42 VIJAY KIRAN APARTMENTS VICTORIA ROAD VICTORIA LAYOUT BANGALORE-560 047 42.SHRI JAGADISH KUMAR C K SO(A) A/C NO.8337337 AGED ABOUT42YEARS S/O CHANDRASEKHARA PANICKER O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560 007 R/O112 DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX SOMESHWARAPURA ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008 43.SHRI S ARUMUGAM SO(A) A/C NO.8338397 AGED ABOUT45YEARS S/O LATE S S RAGHAVAN PILLAI O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD52AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560 007 R/O C-17/19 DAD QUARTERS SOMESHWARAPURA ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008 44.SMT.V BHUVANESWARI AAO A/C NO.8327144 AGED ABOUT50YEARS W/O N VENKATACHALAM O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560 007 R/O MATHURA, D-2 BLOCK V, ANNASANDRAPALYA MAL PO BANGALORE-560 017 45.SMT SEEMA K B SO(A) A/C NO.8337233 AGED ABOUT42YEARS D/O K M BABU O/O PAO ASC SOUTH LOWER AGRAM ROAD AGRAM POST BANGALORE-560 007 R/O141 DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX SOMESHWARAPURA ULSOOR BANGALORE-560 008 53 46.SMT MAYA ARUN AAO A/C NO.8334432 AGED ABOUT37YEARS W/O B ARUN O/O THE CDA (R & D) C V RAMAN NAGAR BANGALORE R/O #106 FALCON NEST APARTMENT1T A CROSS KAGGADASAPURA C V RAMAN NAGAR BANGALORE-93 47.SHRI TVS RAMA KRISHNA AAO A/C NO.8337294 AGED ABOUT41YEARS S/O T V S CHALAPATHI RAO O/O THE CDA (R & D) C V RAMAN NAGAR BANGALORE-93 R/O SH-1/7 DRDO PHASE1C V RAMAN NAGAR BANGALORE-93 48.S NAGABHUSHANA REDDY AAO A/C NO.8332461 AGED ABOUT50YEARS S/O LATE S THIPPA REDDY O/O THE CDA (R & D) 54 C V RAMAN NAGAR BANGALORE R/O C-13/8 DRDO TOWNSHIP PHASE-I C V RAMAN NAGAR BANGALORE-93 49.SHRI. RAJESH WILLIAMS SO (A), A/C No.8339962, AGED ABOUT41YEARS, W/O. WILLIAMS MASCREEN, O/O THE CDA (R & D), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93, R/O. B-9/10, DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX, CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8. 50.SHRI. SIMANCHAN MOHAPATRO AAO, A/C No.8338804, AGED ABOUT55YEARS, S/O. BANCHANIDI MOHAPATRO, O/O. THE CDA RTC (SR), DRDO TOWNSHIP, PHASE-1, C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE, R/O. C-4/13, DRDO TOWNSHIP, PHASE-1, C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93. 51.SHRI. VENUGOPAL M AAO, A/C. NO.8333401, AGED ABOUT44YEARS, S/O. MAHALINGE GOWDA, O/O THE CDA (R & D), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE, 55 RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX, R/O. C-39/12, DRDRO TOWNSHIP, PHASE-II, KAGGADASAPURA, BANGALORE-93. 52.SHRI. J.V. SUBBA RAO AAO, A/C No.8336341, AGED ABOUT43YEARS, S/O. LATE SHRI. J.

RADHA KRISHNA MURTHY, O/O THE CDA (R & D), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE, R/O. B-13/06, DAD CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8. 53.SHRI. JOSEPH THOMAS CHIRACKAL SAO, A/C No.8331564, AGED ABOUT49YEARS, S/O. LATE SHRI. C.J.

THOMAS, O/O. THE CDA (R & D ), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93, R/O. B-14/7, DAD RESI, COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8. 54.SHRI. T.A. SRINIVASA AAO, A/C No.8334442, AGED ABOUT45YEARS, S/O. SHRI. C. ANJANEYA, O/O. THE AO(R & D ), DFRL, SIDDHARTHA NAGAR, MYSORE-11, R/O. QTR. NO.7, TYPE-III, DFRL QUARTERS, SIDDHARTHA NAGAR , MYSORE-11. 56 55.SHRI. C.K. BALAKRISHNAN AAO, A/C. NO.8337364, AGED ABOUT47YEARS, S/O. SHRI. KUNHIKANNAN A.P., O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE, R/O. 2/3, DAD HOSTEL ACCOMMODATION, KAGADASAPURA, C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93. 56.SMT. ANITHA K.N. AAO, A/C. NO.8334451, AGED ABOUT41YEARS, W/O. SHRI. P. MANOJ KUMAR., O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE, R/O. NO.72, GURU REDDY LAYOUT, AKASH NAGAR, B. NARAYANA PURA, K.R. PURAM, BANGALORE-16. 57.SMT. RUCHIKA PRIYADARSHI SO(A), A/C. No.8335895, AGED ABOUT41YEARS, W/O. SHRI. ABHINAV PRIYADARSHI, O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE, R/O. FLAT NO.6 D1, KRISHNA NAGAR APARTMENTS, AANASANDRA PALYA, HAL, VIMANAPURA POST, BANGALORE-17. 58.SHRI. T. SARAVANAN AAO, A/C. NO.8334240, AGED ABOUT39YEARS, 57 CROSS, REDDY LAYOUT, ABBAIAH S/O. SHRI. S.K. TAMIL MANI, O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE, R/O. No.C-45/2, DRDO TOWNSHIP, PHASE-II, KAGGADASAPURA, BANGALORE-93. 59.SHRI. V. N. HARIHARAN AAO, A/C. NO.8334231, AGED ABOUT50YEARS, S/O. V.V. NARAYANA SWAMY, O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE, R/O. FLAT No.003, MATHRU SREE SILVER HOMES, 4TH KAGGADASAPURA, BANGALORE-93. 60.SHRI. MAHENDRA KUMAR L.S. AAO, A/C. NO.8334194, AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O. SHRI. SHIVAMURTHAPPA. L.M., O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93, R/O. KAGGADASAPURA, BANGALORE-93. 61.SHRI. AJAI KUMAR M AAO, A/C. NO.8332686, AGED ABOUT46YEARS, S/O. SHRI. MANIKANTAN NAIR.K, O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93, R/O. NO.C-17/11, DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX, TOWNSHIP, NO.C-39, DRDO PHASE-II, 58 CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8. 62.SHRI. M.K. RAGHUNATH AAO, A/C. NO.8334196, AGED ABOUT48YEARS, S/O. LATE GOVINDAN NAIR, O/O THE PAO (ORS), MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE-560 042, R/O. NO.65, 7TH CROSS, NR. GANESH TEMPLE, BYAPPANAHALLI, INDIRANAGAR POST, BANGALORE-560 038. 63.SHRI. C. P. ANILKUMAR SAO A/C. No.8325382, AGED ABOUT54YEARS, S/O. SHRI. N. P. NARAYANAN, O/O THE PAO (ORS) MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE-560 042, R/O. D-19/3, DAD QTRS, CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT, SOMESWARAPURA EXTENSION, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008. 64.SHRI. E. RAVICHANDER AAO, A/C. NO.8334386, AGED ABOUT50YEARS, S/O. LATE T. ELUMALAI, O/O THE PAO (ORS), MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE-560 042, R/O. NO.17/1, OSBORNE ROAD CROSS, 59 BANGALORE-560 042. 65.SMT. ARUNA SUDHA PARIMALA AAO, A/C. NO.8336504, AGED ABOUT38YEARS, W/O. P. AJAY KUMAR, O/O THE PAO (ORS), MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE-560 042, R/O. NO.B-6/9, DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX, SOMESWARA EXTN, CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT, BANGALORE-560 008. 66.SMT. H. KUSUMA AAO, A/C. NO.8336498, AGED ABOUT43YEARS, W/O. H.V. NARAYANA RAO, O/O THE PAO (ORS), MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE-560 042, R/O.C-17/6, DAD RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX, SOMESWARA EXTN, CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT, BANGALORE-560 008. 67.SMT. REJITHA P.S AAO, A/C. NO.8337365, AGED ABOUT40YEARS, D/O. P.N. SREEDHARAN, O/O THE PAO (ORS), PARA, BANGALORE, R/O. NO.301, 3RD FLOOR, SUNDHER MANOR, N.P. FACTORY ROAD, KAVAL BYRA SANDRA, R.T. NAGAR POST, BANGALORE. 60 68.SMT. N. PREMA AAO, A/C. NO.8329054, AGED ABOUT48YEARS, D/O. LATE G. NATARAJAN, O/O THE PAO (ORS), PARA, BANGALORE, R/O. NO.10/1, 5TH CROSS, GOPALAPPA LAYOUT, MANORANJANA PALYA, R.T. NAGAR, BANGALORE. PRESENTLY WORKING AT O/O. AO GE (I) R & D (EAST/WEST) C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 093. 69.SMT. SIVAPRIYA KARTHIK AO, A/C. No.8334387, AGED ABOUT38YEARS, W/O. SHRI. R. KARTHIK, O/O THE PAO (ORS) MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE-560 042, R/O. No.D-19/7, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8. 70.SMT. MALATHI DAYAN AAO, A/C. NO.8336463, AGED ABOUT41YEARS, W/O. MOSES DAYAN, O/O. THE PAO (ORS) MEG & CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE-560 042, R/O. No.18/2, 2ND LANE, 2ND CROSS, KANAKADASA LAYOUT, LINGARAJAPURAM, BANGALORE. 61 71.SHRI. S.G. SRIKUMAR AAO, A/C. No.8334083, AGED ABOUT45YEARS, S/O. SRI. K. SIVASANKARAN NAIR, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007, R/O. NO.C-18/2, DAD RESI, COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8. 72.SHRI. GIRISHKUMAR V.G AAO, A/C. No.8334390, AGED ABOUT38YEARS, S/O. SRI. V.P. GOPALAKRISHNAN NAIR, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007, R/O. NO.C-18/8, DAD RESI, COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8. 73.SHRI M BALASUBRAMANIAN AAO, A/C NO.8338438, AGED ABOUT43YEARS, S/O SHRI E MANTHIRAN, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007 R/O NO.2644, 3RD CROSSM18H MAIN, HAL STAGE II, BANGALORE74SHRI MADHU SUDHAN AAO, A/C NO.8336299, AGED ABOUT37YEARS, 62 S/O SHRI GOPAL SWAMY, O/O THE PAO(ORS) PCTC, NO.99, DICKENSON ROAD, BANGALORE-42 R/O B-1/6, DAD RESI, COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8 PRESENTLY WORKING AT O/O RAO MES, No.99, DICKENSON ROAD, BANGALORE-560 042. 75.SHRI K SUNILKUMAR SAO, A/C NO.8334184 AGED ABOUT43YEARS, S/O SHRI A KARUNAKARAN, O/O THE PAO(ORS) PCTC, NO.99, DICKENSON ROAD, BANGALORE-42 R/O NO.3460, 13TH A MAIN, HAL2D STAGE, INDIRANAGAR, BANGALORE-8 76.SMT SRILAKSHMI AAO, A/C NO.8336458 AGED ABOUT45YEARS, W/O SHRI V SUBRAMANYAM, OFFICE OF THE DPDO,(UNDER CDA, CHENNAI), DICKENSON ROAD, BANGALORE-42 R/O C-12/9, DRDO TOWN SHIP, PHASE-1, C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BENGALURU-93 77.SHRI G VENKATA KRISHNA AAO, A/C NO.8336289, AGED ABOUT38YEARS, S/O PULLESHWARA RAO, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007 R/O C-18/6, DAD RESI.COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8 63 78.SHRI R SURESH MAHENDRA AAO, A/C NO.8325648, AGED ABOUT49YEARS, S/O SHRI C RAJANNA, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007 R/O NO.68, RHCS LAYOUT, SRIGANDHA KAVAL, NAGARABHAVI, BANGALORE-94 79.SHRI RAMA MUTHANANITHA PERUMAL AAO, A/C NO.8332754 AGED ABOUT38YEARS, S/O SHRI RAMA SUBRAMANIAN, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560007 R/O SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8 80.SHRI TOM JOSEPH AAO, A/C NO.8333449, AGED ABOUT42YEARS, S/O SHRI JOHN JOSEPH, O/O THE DCDA(DAD)HAL, BANGALORE COMPLEX, VIMANPURA POST, BANGALORE-17, R/O C-18/24, DAD RESI COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8 81.SHRI T. SREEHARI AAO, A/C. No.8336531, AGED ABOUT38YEARS, S/O. SHRI. T. SUBBARAYUDU, O/O. THE DCA (DAD) HAL, BANGALORE COMPLEX, C-17/3, DAD RESI, COMPLEX, 64 VIMANPURA POST , BANGALORE17 R/O. C-16/11, DAD RESI COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE0882.SHRI. H B DAKSHINA MURTHY AAO, A/C. No.8338414, AGED BOUT42YEARS, S/O. SHRI BASAVARAJAIAH, O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000. R/O. No.3353, 6TH MAIN, 3RD CROSS, RPC LAYOUT, VIJAYANAGAR, BANGALORE4083.SMT. L. SREE KUMARI AAO, A/C, No.8325645, AGED ABOUT50YEARS, W/O. K. RAMARAJAN, O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000. R/O. 41/1, VIGNESH NIVAS, 8TH CROSS, VIGNANA NAGAR, NEW THIPPASANDRA, BANGALORE75 PRESENTLY WORKING AT O/O. THE PAO (ORS) ASC AT AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000 84.SMT. V. KAVITHA SAO, A/C. No.8332533, AGED ABOUT45YEARS, W/O. SHRI. M N VIJAYA KUMAR, O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, 65 AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000. R/O. No.8, 6TH MAIN, CHIKKADUGODI, D.R. COLLEGE POST, BANGALORE56002. PRESENTLY WORKING AT O/O THE AO, GE (AF), YELAHANKA, BANGALORE56006 85.SMT. M. CHITTI SNEHALATHA AAO, A/C No.8332367, AGED ABOUT49YEARS, W/O. SHRI. SESHU BABU P O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000. R/O. No.108, SRI. SAPAGIRI MEDOWS, OGANHALLI ROAD, PANATHUR, BANGALORE10386.SHRI. S. SHASI KUMAR SO (A) A/C. No.8339174 AGED ABOUT40YEARS, S/O. SHRI. VENKATA MALLAIAH O/O THE PCDA, No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000. R/O. No.B-12/10. DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE0887.SHRI. P. RAVI KANTH SO (A) A/C. No.8339210 AGED ABOUT39YEARS, S/O. P. SRINIVASA RAO O/O THE PCDA, No.107, 66 LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE56000. R/O. No.B-8/13. DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE0888.SHRI. S BADARI NARAYANA SO (A) A/C. No.8339204 AGED ABOUT39YEARS, S/O. SHRI. S. SUBBA RAO O/O THE PAO (ORS) CMP, NELLASANDRA, BANGALORE R/O. No.B-5/10. DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE0889.SMT. LEENA LASKAR SO(A), A/C NO.8336958, AGED ABOUT38YEARS W/O SHRI DEBOJYOTI LASHKAR, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE560007 R/O Q.NO.2/8, DAD HOSTEL TYPE ACCOMMODATION, 1ST "A" MAIN CROSS, KAGGADASAPURA MAIN ROAD, CV, RAMAN NAGAR BANGALORE - 93. 90.SMT. A JAYA BHARATHI SAO A/C NO.8333460, AGED ABOUT42YEARS W/O SHRI ANANDA DASS O/O THE AO GE (NORTH), MEANEE LINES, MEG & CENTRE, BANGALORE42R/O NO.490, 2ND FLOOR, 6TH "D" CROSS, 6TH BLOCK, KORAMANGALA, BANGALORE. 67 91.SMT. BARKHA RANI AAO, A/C NO.8337377, AGED ABOUT38YEARS W/O RAMESH PRASAD, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE560007. R/O B-4/3, DAD RESI. COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE-8 92.SHRI A LOURDES THEODRE AAO, A/C NO.8325588,AGED ABOUT52YEARS, S/O J.

ARULDOSS O/O THE CDA (R&D), C.V. RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE R/O16, DAD HOSTEL ACCOMMODATION KAGADASAPUA, C.V. RAMAN NAGAR,BANGALORE-93. 93.SHRI. M BALASUBRAMANIAN AAO, A/C NO.8338438, AGED ABOUT43YEARS S/O SHRI E MANTHIRAN, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE560007 R/O NO.2644, 3RD CROSS, 18TH MAIN, HAL STAGE II, BANGALORE. 94.SHRI. SATHEESHKUMAR V AAO, A/C NO.8334402 AGED ABOUT42YEARS S/O SHRI A. VELAPPAN PILLAI, O/O THE PCDA, NO.107 LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE560007. R/O Q.NO.2/5, DAD HOSTEL ACCOMMODATION KAGGADASAPURA MAIN ROAD, 68 C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-93. 95.SHRI AVATAPALLI SRINIVAS AO, A/C No.8336251 AGED ABOUT46YEARS, S/O SHRI V A KRISHNA MURTHY, HQRS JL WING INFANTRY SCHOOL, BELGAUM - 09 R/O FLAT No.77, 5TH STAGE, HANUMAN NAGAR, DOUBLE ROAD, BELGAUM - 01. 96.SMT. B CHITRA AAO A/C No.8338429 AGED ABOUT37YEARS, W/O G MAHESH O/O THE PAO (ORS) MEG AND CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE - 560 042 R/O FLAT No.G3, SRI RANGA APTS No.22, CAR STREET, HALASURU, BANGALORE - 560 008. 97.SHRI C SREENIVASAMURTHY AAO, A/C No.8325428 AGED ABOUT51YEARS, S/O LATE CHINNAIAH O/O THE PAO (ORS) MEG AND CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE - 560 042. R/O No.20/2, PETTIGREW STREET, BHARATHINAGAR, BANGALORE - 560 001. 98.SHRI R SREEKUMAR SO (A) A/C No.8339260 AGED ABOUT55YEARS, S/O LATE K RAGHAVAN NAIR O/O THE PAO (ORS) MEG AND CENTRE, OLD MADRAS ROAD, BANGALORE - 560 042 69 R/O No.B2/8, DAD RESIDENTIAL QTRS. SOMESWARAPURA EXTN. CAMBRIDGE LAYOUT, ULSOOR, BANGALORE - 560 008. 99.SHRI T THENNARASU AAO A/C No.8331994 AGED ABOUT44YEARS, S/O LATE ELA THAMIL SELVAN OFFICE OF THE LAO (AF) JALAHALLI (WEST) BANGALORE - 15 R/O C-18/14 DAD RESI COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE - 8. 100.SHRI A N V RAMANJANEYULU SO (A) A/C No.8345590 AGED ABOUT32YEARS, S/O SHRI A PULLESWARA RAO, O/O THE PCDA No.107, LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE - 560 007 R/O B-14/2, DAD RESI COMPLEX, SOMESHWARAPURA, ULSOOR, BANGALORE -8. ... PETITIONERS (BY SRI ONKARA K B, ADVOCATE) AND1THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVT. OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF FINANCE, DEPARTMENT OF EXPENDITURE, NORTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI11000 70 2.THE MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL PUBLIC GRIEVANCES AND PENSIONS, REP BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL AND TRAINING, NEW DELHI-110 001 3.THE MINISTRY OF DEFENCE (FINANCE) REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, ESTABLISHMENT-1 SECTION, NEW DELHI-110 001 4.THE CONTROLLER GENERAL OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS ULAN BATAR ROAD, PALAM, DELHI CANTT-110010 5.THE PRINCIPAL CONTROLLER OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 6.CONTROLLER OF DEFENSE ACCOUNTS (R AND D)C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560093 7.CONTROLLER OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS (SR) REGIONAL TRAINING CENTRE, DRDO PHASE-II, KAGGADASAPURA,C.V.RAMAN NAGAR, BANGALORE-560093 8.CONTROLLER OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS NO.618,ANNA SALAI, TEYNAMPET, CHENNAI-600018 9.JOINT CONTROLLER OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS(AF) VAYUSENA NAGAAR, NAGPUR -440007 71 INTEGRATED FINANCIAL ADVISER (COAST GUARD) NATIONAL STADIUM COMPLEX, NEW DELHI-110 001 10.INTEGRATED FINANCIAL ADVISER (COAST GUARD) NATIONAL STADIUM COMPLEX, NEW DELHI-110 001 ... RESPONDENTS (BY SRI C. SHASHIKANTHA, CGC FOR R1 TO R10) THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLES226AND227OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO MODIFY THE

JUDGMENT

PASSED BY THE HON'BLE CAT BANGALORE BENCH IN O.A.NO.1056 TO11712015 ON218.2015 VIDE ANNEX- B, SO FAR AS HOLDING THAT, THE BENEFITS/ MONETARY CONSEQUENCES SHALL BE MADE AVAILABLE ONLY FROM THE DATE OF THE BOMBAY BENCH

JUDGMENT

AND THAT BENEFITS MAY BE EXTENDED FROM288.2014 IS CONCERNED. IN W.P.NO.53277/2016 & W.P.NOS.54817-818/2016 BETWEEN1SRI RAMAN K AO (RETD), A/C NO.8320752 AGED ABOUT61YEARS, S/O LATE P.KANNAN, O/O PAY ACCOUNTS OFFICER(ORS) CMP, BANGALORE-560047 R/O L.5, "ANNAPOORNA" KRISTAL CAMPUS-10 CORAL-3 72 YAMARE, SARJAPURA ROAD, BANGALORE-562125 2.SRI.N.Y.MUTHAIYA AAO, (RETD), A/C831829 AGED ABOUT63YEARS, S/O SHRI Y.YOHANNAN, O/O PCDA MEG, BANGALORE-560042 FLAT NO.305, B.M.SILVER OAKS TRINITY COMPLEX, SOMAPURA GATE, SARJAPURA MAIN ROAD, BANGALORE-562125 3.SRI.P.K.OMANAKUTTAN AO, (RETD), A/C830551 AGED ABOUT63YEARS, S/O SHRI.SREEJIT S.R, O/O PARO (ORS)MEG AND C, BANGALORE-560042 FLAT NO.113, INDWIN ECSTACY, 9TH MAIN, G.B.PALYA ROAD, HONGASANDRA, BANGALORE-560068 ... PETITIONERS (BY SRI ONKARA K B, ADVOCATE) AND1THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVT. OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF FINANCE, DEPARTMENT OF EXPENDITURE, NORTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI-110 001 73 2.THE MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL PUBLIC GRIEVANCES AND PENSIONS REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL AND TRAINING, NEW DELHI-110 001 3.THE MINISTRY OF DEFENCE (FINANCE) REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, ESTABLISHMENT-1 SECTION, NEW DELHI-110 001 4.THE CONTROLLER GENERAL OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS ULAN EATAR ROAD, PALAM, DELHI CANTT-110010 5.THE PRINCIPAL CONTROLLER OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE-560 007 ... RESPONDENTS (BY SRI C.SHASHIKANTHA, CGC) THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLES226AND227OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO MODIFY THE

JUDGMENT

PASSED BY THE HON'BLE CAT BANGALORE BENCH IN O.A.NO.170/01171 TO11742015 ON218.2015 VIDE ANNEX-B, SO FAR AS HOLDING THAT, THE BENEFITS/ MONETARY CONSEQUENCES SHALL BE MADE AVAILABLE ONLY FROM THE DATE OF THE BOMBAY BENCH

JUDGMENT

AND THAT BENEFITS MAY BE EXTENDED FROM288.2014 IS CONCERNED. 74 IN W.P.NOS.53575-53577/2016 BETWEEN1THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVT OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF FINANCE, DEPARTMENT OF EXPENDITURE NORTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI - 110 001. 2.THE MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL PUBLIC GRIEVANCES AND PENSIONS, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL AND TRAINING, NEW DELHI - 110 001. 3.THE MINISTRY OF DEFENCE (FINANCE) REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY ESTABLISHMENT1SECTION, NEW DELHI - 110 001. 4.THE CONTROLLER GENERAL OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS ULLAN BATAR ROAD, PALAM, DELHI CANTT - 110 010. 5.THE PRINCIPAL CONTROLLER OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS107 LOWER AGRAM ROAD, AGRAM POST, BANGALORE - 560 007. (BY SRI SHASHIKANTHA C, CGC) ... PETITIONERS75AND1K RAMAN AO (RETD) A/C No.8320752 AGED ABOUT60YEARS, S/O LATE P KANNAN, O/O PAY ACCOUNTS OFFICE (ORS) CMP, BANGALORE - 560 047 R/O L.5, ANNAPOORNA, KRISTAL CAMPUS - 10 CORAL3 YAMARE, SARJAPURA ROAD, BANGALORE - 562 125. 2.N.Y. MUTHAIYA AAO, (RETD) A/C No.8318269 AGED ABOUT63YEARS, S/O SHRI Y YOHANAN, O/O PAO (ORS) MEG, BANGALORE - 560 042. FLAT No.305, B.M.SILVER OAKS TRINITY COMPLEX, SOMAPURA GATE, SARJAPURA MAIN ROAD, BANGALORE - 562 125. 3.SHRI P.K. OMANAKUTTAN AO, (RETD) A/C No.8305541 AGED ABOUT63YEARS, S/O SHRI SREEJIT S.R. O/O PAO (ORS) MEG AND C, BANGALORE - 560 042 R/O FLAT - 113 INDWIN-ECSTASY9H MAIN, G.B.PALAYA ROAD, HONGASANDRA, BANGALORE - 560 068. 76 ... RESPONDENTS (BY SRI ONKARA K B, ADVOCATE FOR C/R1-R3) THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLES226AND227OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE

ORDER

DTD.21.8.2015 PASSED IN O.A.NOS.170/01172 TO11742015 PASSED BY THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, BANGALORE BENCH, BANGALORE VIDE ANENX-A TO THE W.P. THESE PETITIONS COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING THIS DAY, JAYANT PATEL J., PASSED THE FOLLOWING:

ORDER

As in all the petitions common order of the Tribunal is under challenge, they have been considered simultaneously. All petitions are directed against the order dated 21.8.2015 passed by the Tribunal in the respective OA whereby the Tribunal for the reasons recorded in the order has directed the respondents to extend the benefit of higher Grade Pay from 28.8.2014. 77 2. We may record that so far as respondent- authorities are concerned, they have preferred W.P.Nos. 51098/2016 & 54922-55037/2016 and W.P.Nos. 53575-53577/2016 for challenging the legality and validity of the order passed by the Tribunal for grant of benefit as mentioned in the order of the Tribunal. Whereas, some of the original applicants before the Tribunal have preferred W.P.Nos. 53273/2016 & 54819- 917/2016 and W.P. Nos. 53277 & 54817-818/2016 for challenging the order passed by the Tribunal so far as it relates to not granting the benefit from 1.9.2008 to 28.8.2014 (which is the date fixed by the Tribunal for conferment of the benefit in the impugned order).

3. As per the order passed by this Court today in the respective matters, W.P.Nos.53575-53577/2016 are 78 also included, with the consent of learned Counsel appearing for both the sides.

4. The parties in the present proceedings shall be referred as ‘employees concerned’ so far as it relates to the original applicants before the Tribunal and shall be referred to the ‘respondent-authorities’ so far as it relates to respondents before the Tribunal, since there are cross petitions preferred by the employees as well as by the respondent-authorities challenging the very common order of the Tribunal.

5. The short relevant facts are that all employees were initially appointed as Auditors/Data Entry Operators/Clerks, after the recruitment process was undertaken by the concerned department of the respondent-authority. As per the case of the employees they were promoted to the post of Section Officer 79 (Accounts) (‘SO-A’ in short) after passing Departmental Subordinate Accounting Service Examination which is a mandatory requirement. The said promotional post is re-designated as Assistant Accounts Officer which is a Group ‘B’ Gazetted post and some of the employees thereafter have also got further promotions in the hierarchy of Accounts Officers and Senior Accounts Officers. The grievance on the part of the employees were that those Auditors/Data Entry Operators/Clerks who could not get promotion for one reason or the another, were granted benefit of MACP scheme on account of their length of service, 1st MACP, 2nd MACP or 3rd MACP, as the case may be. But on account of the said benefit of MACP conferred due to length of service they were in the Grade Pay of Rs.5,400/- after 6th Pay Commission recommendations were accepted whereas the employees who were on the higher post after getting 80 promotion were placed in the lower Grade Pay of Rs.4,200/- or Rs.4,800/- as the case may be as per the 6th Pay Commission recommendation. The grievance on the part of the employees was that the persons working in the feeder cadre on account of their length of service gets higher Grade Pay in comparison to the employees who were working on the higher post. As per the employees it was required for the respondent- authorities to step up the pay scale of the employees by putting them in the Grade Pay of Rs.5,400/- but as such was not undertaken they preferred OAs before the Tribunal praying relief inter alia to direct the respondent-authorities to grant the Grade Pay of Rs.5,400/- to the employees with arrears and all consequential benefits and it was alternatively prayed to extend the benefits as per the order passed by Madras Bench of the Tribunal read with the decision of the High 81 Court of Madras read with the decision of the Apex Court in the SLP. The Tribunal ultimately vide the impugned order found that the matter is covered by the decision of Madras Bench as well as Bombay Bench of the Tribunal dated 29.12.2010 and 17.11.2004 respectively and the Tribunal took note of the fact that the jurisdictional High Court confirmed the said decision of the Tribunal and the Apex Court in the SLP found no merit. The Tribunal, therefore, ultimately allowed the Applications but for the monetary consequences, the Tribunal found that it should follow from the date of the OA. However, as there was decision of the Bombay Bench of the Tribunal, the Tribunal instead granting benefit as per the decision of Madras Bench of the Tribunal, directed the benefit to be conferred from 28.8.2014 by exercising the discretion. Under the circumstances, the present petitions before 82 this Court. We have already recorded earlier that the respondent-authorities as well as the employees have preferred cross petitions against the very order of the Tribunal. In the petitions of the respondent-authorities it has been contended that no benefit ought to have been granted by the Tribunal whereas in the petitions preferred by the employees it has been contended that the benefit ought to have granted from 1.9.2008 and not from 28.8.2014 as directed by the Tribunal. Hence, the petitions before this Court.

6. We have heard Mr. C.Shashikantha, the learned Central Government Standing Counsel for the respondent-authorities and Mr. Onkara K.B, learned counsel appearing for the employees.

7. It has been contended on behalf of the respondent-authorities that on the basis of MACP83scheme, by virtue of clause 20, stepping up is not permitted at all and he further submitted that, after the decision of Madras Bench of the Tribunal and the High Court of Madras and the decision of the Apex Court as well as after the decision of the Bombay Bench of the Tribunal, the Principal Bench of the Tribunal at Delhi has considered all the aspects and has found vide its order dated 26.11.2015 that the upgradation of the Grade Pay is not available to the applicant therein who are in par with the employees herein and, therefore, he submitted that the order passed by the Tribunal deserves to be set aside. He alternatively contended that the OAs before the Tribunal were filed on 14.8.2015 and hence the Tribunal even if it was to extend the benefit could not extend the benefit prior to the date of filing of OA and, therefore, in any case the benefit so ordered by the Tribunal from 28.8.2014 84 deserves to be modified from the date of filing of the Application before the Tribunal, i.e., 14.8.2015 and hence this Court may interfere to that part of the order.

8. Learned counsel appearing for the employees contended inter alia that the issues are squarely covered by not only the decision of Madras Bench of the Tribunal as well as Bombay Bench of the Tribunal but also by the decision of the High Court of Madras against which the SLP was dismissed by the Apex Court. As per the contention of the learned counsel appearing for the employees, on the contrary, the Tribunal committed error in restricting the benefit from 28.8.2014 but as per his submission it should have been from 1.9.2008 and, therefore, this Court while dismissing the petitions preferred by the respondent-authorities may modify the order passed by the Tribunal for fixing the date for conferment of the benefit with effect from 1.9.2008. 85 9. We may at the outset record that on following factual aspects there is no dispute: - (1) All employees were appointed as Auditors/Data Entry Operators/Clerks. (2) They were promoted to the post of Section Officer (Accounts) after passing Departmental Subordinate Accounting Service Examination. (3) The aforesaid post of Section Officer (Accounts) is re-designated as Assistant Accounts Officer. (4) Certain employees from the present group have also got further promotion as Accounts Officer and Senior Accounts Officer. (Of course, the aforesaid aspect is not much relevant for the purpose of examining the controversy raised in the present matters) (5) All other persons (other than the employees who were promoted) working as Auditors/Data Entry 86 Operators/Clerks have been granted MACP benefit on account of their requisite length of service as per the MACP scheme and after revision of pay scale as per 6th Pay Scale recommendation they are given Grade Pay of Rs.5,400/-. (6) The employees concerned after their promotion on the higher post of Section Officer (Accounts)/Assistant Accounts Officer are granted pay revision as per the 6th Pay Commission and placed in the Grade Pay of Rs.4,200/- or Rs.4,800/-, as the case may be, on the basis of length of service. (7) None of the employees have been placed in the Grade Pay of Rs.5,400/- at par with the Grade Pay of the other persons who were conferred benefit as per the MACP scheme in the cadre of 87 Auditors/Data Entry Operators/Clerks, as the case may be.

10. We may broadly state that if one is working in the higher post, his payscale is supposed to be and expected to be higher in comparison to the payscale of a person working in the lower cadre. Such principle needs to be observed even in a case where on account of MACP scheme conferred upon the employee working in the lower cadre on completion of requisite length of service. But when such contingency arises that the person working in the higher cadre is receiving lesser payscale in comparison to the person working in the lower cadre, the question of stepping up at the time of revision of payscale would normally arise and such stepping up is required to be considered so as to make sure that the person working in the higher cadre does 88 not get, in any case, lesser payscale in comparison to the person working in the lower cadre.

11. As such, the aforesaid contingencies had arisen at the time when there was revision of the payscale in the cadre of Auditor/Data Entry Operator in comparison to the payscale of Section Officer (Accounts) redesignated as Asst. Accounts Officer. At this stage, we may usefully refer to the decision of Division Bench of Madras High Court in W.P.No.18611/2011 and allied matters decided on 19.03.2014. In the said decision, identical question came up for consideration for the very post and the fixation of payscale for Section Officers in comparison to the payscale of Clerks.

12. The Madras Bench of the Tribunal held that the employees working in the higher cadre of the Accountants promoted from the cadre of clerk would be entitled to Grade Pay of Rs.5,400/- from the date on 89 which the said benefit was extended to the other employees working in the lower cadre, were granted benefit of the Grade Pay of Rs.5,400/-. The appeal was preferred against the said decision of the Tribunal dated 29.12.2010 in O.A.Nos.966/2009 and another before the High Court of Madras in the above referred writ petitions. The Madras High Court after considering the submissions of the parties observed at paragraphs-6 to 13 as under:

6. It is relevant to extract Government of India orders to FR-22 (I)(a), which reads as follows: “Removal of anomaly by stepping up of pay of Senior on promotion drawing less pay than his junior.- … (d) the anomaly should be directly as a result of the application of the provisions of Fundamental Rule 22 or any other rule or order regulating pay 90 fixation on such promotion in the revised scale. If even in the lower post, the junior officer was drawing more pay in the pre-revised scale than the senior by virtue of any advance increments granted to him, provisions of this Note need not be invoked to step up the pay of the senior officer.” For invoking the said provision, two conditions have to be fulfilled and the first is that junior as well as senior employees must be promoted and consequently they must come from the same cadre, having same scale of pay in the feeder post.

7. It is the vehement submission of the learned counsel appearing for the writ petitioners that in view of MACP Scheme which came into being in the year 2009, FR- 22(I)(a)(i) has no application and since the private respondents 4 to 26 in the original applications are stagnated without any 91 promotion, they have been rightly conferred with the benefit of pay grade of Rs.5,400/- and also contented that in the absence of any challenge to the said scheme, it is not open to the private respondents to attack the said benefit conferred on them. In the considered opinion of the Court, the said submission lacks merit and substance for the reason that any action of the State has to pass the test of reasonableness and shall not offend Article 14 of the Constitution of India.

8. In State of Andhra Pradesh V. G.Sreenivasa Rao [(1989) 2 SCC290, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has observed as follows: “15. “Equal pay for equal work” does not mean that all the members of a cadre must receive the same pay packet irrespective of their seniority, source of recruitment, educational qualifications and various other incidents of service. When a single running pay scale is provided in a cadre the 92 constitutional mandate of equal pay for equal work is satisfied. Ordinarily grant of higher pay to a junior would ex facie be arbitrary but if there are justifiable grounds in doing so the seniors cannot invoke the equality doctrine. To illustrate, when pay fixation is done under valid statutory rules/executive instructions, when persons recruited from different sources are given pay protection, when promotee from lower cadre or a transferee from another cadre is given pay protection, when a senior is stopped at efficiency bar, when advance increments are given for experience/passing a test/acquiring higher qualifications or incentive for efficiency; are some of the eventualities when a junior may be drawing higher pay than his seniors without violating the mandate of equal pay for equal work. The differentia on these grounds would be based on intelligible criteria which has rational nexus with the object sought to be achieved….” 93 As per the above decision, ordinarily grant of higher pay to a junior would be ex-facie be arbitrary but, if there are justifiable ground in doing so, the seniors cannot invoke the equality doctrine.

9. ‘The facts of the present case would disclose that the private respondents herein got promoted on account of passing departmental tests on time, but the private respondents 4 to 26 in the original applications did not pass the said test in time and therefore, they got stagnated and admittedly, both of them hailing from a same cadre and the private respondents 4 to 26 in the original applications were given promotion as Section Officers (adhoc) without any supervisory power and they have to work under the private respondents herein.

10. It is also held in the above cited decision that the differentia on these grounds would be based on intelligible criteria which has 94 rational nexus with the object sought to be achieved and in the case on hand, the private respondents 4 to 26 did not pass the departmental test on time and got stagnated and by granting them higher grade of pay of Rs.5,400/-, the petitioners/appellants herein indirectly putting premium on their inefficiency. It is fairly submitted by the learned counsel appearing for the private respondents that there are not interested in deprivation of the said benefit conferred on the private respondents 4 to 26, but what they pray is that the original applicants/private respondents who are in the grade pay of Rs.4,500/- are to be given the benefit of grade pay of Rs.5,400/-, as given to their juniors of the private respondents 4 to 26 in the original applications.

11. The appellants herein, under the guise of MACP scheme dated 19.05.2009 coupled with the clarification dated 09.11.2009, seeks to deprive the benefit of FR-22(1) (a) (i) to the private 95 respondents and in the considered opinion of the Court, it is unsustainable as it violates equality and it also offends Article 14 of the Constitution of India and the MACP scheme dated 19.05.2009 as well as the impugned order dated 03.08.2009 do not spell out any reason the applicability of FR-22(1) (a) (i), has excluded for the persons like private respondents who are ultimately aggrieved/affected.

12. The Government of India passed series of orders issuing clarification in respect of FR-22 (I) (a) (i) and as per Clarification No.23(d), the pay anomaly should be directed as a result of the application of the provisions of Fundamental Rule 22 or any other rule or order regulating pay fixation of such promotion in the revised scale. (emphasis supplied) 13. In the case on hand, the private respondents 4 to 26 in the original applications are admittedly juniors to the private respondents in these writ 96 petitions and they did not qualify on time for getting their promotion and consequently got stagnated and on account of the same, they are not conferred with higher grade pay of Rs.5,400/- . The Tribunal has taken into consideration of the fact that admittedly the private respondents 4 to 26 did not pass the departmental test on time and got stagnated at the level of Senior Accountants and since they have been conferred with higher grade pay of Rs.5,400/-, has rightly granted the said relief in their favour. It is to be pointed out at this juncture that the private respondents 4 to 26 in the original applications have not been put to any prejudice and what the Tribunal done was, merely stepped up the pay scale of the original applicants to that of the private respondents 4 to 26 and it is in tune with the principle of parity and equity enshrined in Article 14 of the Constitution of India.” 13. Thereafter, ultimately the Madras High Court did not interfere with the order passed by the Tribunal 97 having found that there is no error apparent or infirmity in the reasons assigned by the Tribunal in allowing the main original applications and the petitions were dismissed.

14. We may also record that thereafter the aforesaid view taken by Madras High Court in the above referred writ petition has also been subsequently followed by Madras High Court in its decision dated 03.04.2014 in W.P.No.1078/2012 and allied matters wherein similar order passed by the Madras Bench of the Tribunal were under challenge in respect certain other employees similarly situated.

15. At this stage, we may also record that the aforesaid decision of Madras High Court dated 19.03.2014 in W.P.No.18612/2011 was carried by the respondent-authority before the Apex Court in SLP (C) 98 No.11103/2014 and the Apex Court vide order dated 19.08.2014 passed the following order: “Delay condoned. We find no merit in this petition. The Special Leave Petition is dismissed. However, the question of law is left open.” 16. As such, one can say that in view of the above referred order of the Apex Court, the view taken by the High Court of Madras was not interfered with by the Apex Court in the SLP, but of course, as the question of law was left open, it can be said that the question of law did not get concluded by the Apex Court.

17. We may also record that more or less similarly situated one of the Asst. Accounts Officer, Mr.Sanjay B.Shetty and Others had preferred Original Applications before the Bombay Bench of the Tribunal for similar 99 relief. In the said Original Applications, the Bombay Bench of the Tribunal vide order dated 17.11.2014 directed the respondents-authorities to grant the revised pay to the applicants therein by fixing the grade pay of Rs.5,400/- from the date on which the said benefit was extended to the subordinates and juniors to the applicants therein.

18. However, the learned Counsel appearing for the respondents-authorities by strongly relying upon the decision of the Principal Bench of the Tribunal in O.A.No.436/2015 decided on 26.11.2015 contended that in the said decision, the Principal Bench of the Tribunal has considered the earlier decisions of Madras Bench of the Tribunal, the decision of the High Court of Madras as well as the dismissal of SLP by the Apex Court and also the order passed by other benches of the Tribunal and thereafter the Principal bench of Tribunal 100 has found that since the consolidated salary drawn by the applicant-employee is higher in comparison to the consolidated salary of the employee working in the lower cadre, the stepping up cannot be granted. It has been further observed that in view of Clause-20 of the MACP scheme, providing for no additional financial upgradation to the senior employees on the ground that the junior employee in the grade has got higher pay, the applicant-employee would not be entitled to the upgradation even if they are promoted. Ultimately, the Principal bench of the Tribunal has dismissed the O.A. made by the employee concerned.

19. The learned Counsel for the respondents- authority contended that the error arisen in the decision of the Madras Bench of the Tribunal or Bombay Bench or the Tribunal as well as the decision of the High Court of Madras were considered and the said decisions were 101 held as per incuriam because Clause-20 of the MACP scheme never came to be considered, coupled with the aspect that it was lost sight of in the said decisions that the consolidated salary of the applicant-employee concerned was in any case higher than the consolidated salary of the junior/persons working in the lower cadre. The learned Counsel submitted that under these circumstances, this Court may not take the same view as was taken by the High Court of Madras, since the dismissal of SLP against the said decision cannot be said as a binding precedent nor the question could be said as concluded by the Apex Court, more particularly, when the Apex Court left the question open even while dismissing the SLP. He therefore submitted that this Court may interfere with the order passed by the Tribunal which has simply gone by the order passed by the Madras Bench of the Tribunal as well as the 102 Bombay Bench of the Tribunal and the decision of the High Court of Madras and the dismissal of SLP against the said order.

20. Whereas the learned Counsel appearing for the employees contended that the view expressed by the Principal Bench of the Tribunal is not correct, apart from the aspects that the decision of the Tribunal will not have any persuasive value when the matter is at the High Court level. He submitted that the High Court of Madras in the above referred decision has well considered all the aspects and the same would hold the field irrespective of the aspect that the question of law at the Supreme Court level is kept open or not.

21. It is true that as such, the decision of the Central Administrative Tribunal may not have persuasive value in comparison to the view taken by any other High Court of the country, but since the question 103 has been examined and the learned Counsel for the respondents-authority has strongly relied upon the said decision for convincing the Court to interfere with the order passed by the Tribunal, we have found it appropriate to consider the said decision of Principal Bench and to deal with the same.

22. In our considered view, the Principal Bench of the Tribunal in the above referred decision has committed error on both the aspects namely, that while relying upon Clause-20 of the MACP Scheme, it has been lost sight of by the Tribunal that clause-20 of MACP scheme would apply only for the senior employee and junior employee working in the same cadre and it cannot be applied to avoid stepping up in case of the employee working in the higher cadre, if he is to get low payscale in comparison to the employee working in the lower cadre who is getting higher payscale. 104 23. On the second aspect, the Principal Bench of the Tribunal has also committed error in considering the availability of stepping up only if the consolidated salary of the senior or a person working in the higher cadre is less than the junior/person working in the lower cadre. It is hardly required to be stated that when one talks for the payscale and the cadre and other allowances attached to that respective post or the cadre would not assume any importance for maintenance of the parity of the payscale as per the respective cadre. When one speaks for cadre vis-à-vis the payscale, it is only the payscale or the grade pay would be holding relevance and not the consolidated salary or the pay which may be arrived at after the respective allowances available to the respective posts. The question of stepping up is to be considered and can be applied for maintaining the parity of the pay scale or grade pay in 105 comparison to the person working in the higher cadre and the person working in the lower cadre on account of length of service or may be on account of the MACP benefit conferred upon the person working in the lower cadre due to completion of requisite length of service. Under these circumstances, we find that both the facets which has been taken as the basis by the Principal bench of the Tribunal for taking a different view, even if considered and examined, the same cannot be said to be valid basis for depriving stepping up of the payscale to the person working in the higher cadre in comparison to the pay scale of the person working in the lower cadre. Hence, we cannot accept the contention raised by the learned Counsel appearing for the respondents- authority.

24. In view of the above observation and discussion, the order passed by the Tribunal directing 106 the benefit of the higher pay scale to the employees working in the higher cadre in the grade pay of Rs.5,400/- would not call for any interference in the petitions preferred by the respondent/Authorities. Hence these petitions deserve to be dismissed.

25. However, as there are cross petitions preferred by the employees so far as the order passed by the Tribunal limiting the benefit of higher grade pay scale from 28.08.2014 only and not granting benefit from 01.09.2008, we may now further examine as to whether the Tribunal has committed any error apparent on the face of record or has exercised jurisdiction in perverse manner or has committed an error of jurisdiction to that extent or not.

26. The learned counsel appearing for the employees contended that once the Tribunal found that the cases were covered by the Madras Bench of the 107 Tribunal, further confirmed by the High Court of Madras as well as the Bombay Bench of the Tribunal, the benefit ought to have been ordered from the date on which the revision of the pay scale was made in respect of the employees working in the lower cadre, i.e., 01.09.2008 and there was no valid reason on the part of the Tribunal to deny the benefit from that date and only to grant benefit from 28.08.2014.

27. Learned counsel submitted that the Tribunal has committed an error apparent on the face of the record to that extent and it can also be said to be a perverse exercise of the discretion by the Tribunal. It is an error of jurisdiction which may be interfered by this court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution. The learned counsel appearing for the employees relied upon a decision of the Apex Court in the case of State of Karnataka and others Vs. C. 108 Lalitha reported in 2006 (2) SCC747and an another decision of the Apex Court in the case of State of Uttar Pradesh and Others Vs. Arvind Kumar Srivastava And Others reported in (2015) 1 SCC347for supporting the contention that the Tribunal ought to have given parity by treating everybody equal for the grant of benefit with effect from 01.09.2008.

28. Whereas, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent/Authority submitted that inspite of full knowledge that the grade pay is lower of the employees working in the higher cadre when the pay scale came to be fixed on 01.09.2008, no grievance was raised at the relevant point of time by any of the employees. Further, the other similarly situated employees who were aggrieved by the lower grade pay, raised the grievance before the Madras and as well as all other Benches of the Tribunal. But the employees in the present case 109 accepted the decision of the Authority or in any case did not challenge the same until the petition came to be filed for the first time in August, 2015. Therefore the Tribunal could be said to have committed an error even for grant of benefit with effect from 28.08.2014, but it ought to have been from the date of the O.A. filed before the Tribunal, which is 14.08.2015. He alternatively submitted that in any case, the Tribunal has exercised the discretion by balancing the rights of both the sides by fixing the date 28.08.2014 and hence the appeals preferred by the employees deserves to be dismissed.

29. As such, the delay in approaching the Tribunal would assume importance when the court has to modulate the relief even if ultimately court finds that there is a case on merit. If there a strong case on merit, but the cause is delayed for a sufficient period and the petitioner concerned has slept over his right, court while 110 modulating the relief may not grant benefit for the period during which the delay has been caused or may confer the benefit appropriately so that no undue benefit is taken by the defaulting party which has caused the delay. In any case, what should be the effective date for the purpose of conferment of the benefit would fall in the arena of exercise of the discretion to be exercised by the Forum or the Court. In the present case, it is undisputed position that Madras Bench of the Tribunal did grant the benefit from the day on which the pay scale was fixed of the persons working in the lower cadre, so is the case for Bombay Bench of the Tribunal.

30. However, such benefit or the same treatment can be made available had the employees approached the Tribunal well in time. For a period of about seven years, the employees have slept over their rights and did 111 not approach before the Tribunal for ventilating their grievances and for the first time in August, 2015 the applications have been preferred. The delay of about seven years cannot be leniently viewed. It is true that getting higher pay scale is a continuous cause and therefore it may not result into dismissal of the petition on the ground of delay. But in our considered view, the question may arise for modulating the relief even if the cause is found to be meritorious since the employees concerned have slept over their rights for a long period of seven years. The administration also cannot be made to suffer on account of the delay or default on the part of employee concerned. If the principle of reasonable period is considered, the cause can be said as agitated beyond reasonable period since the period of seven years cannot be termed as a reasonable period. Under these circumstances, when there was delay of about 112 seven years and the petitioners have approached to the Tribunal for the first time in August, 2015, it appears that the Tribunal has exercised the discretion by granting relief from one year earlier from filing of the petition on 28.08.2014 and has balanced the equities and the rights of both the sides, namely, of the employees as well as the administration. We do not find that the exercise of discretion of the Tribunal can be said to be perverse which may call for interference in exercise of the power under Article 227 of the Constitution. When the circumstances are apparent, calling for the exercise of the discretion for balancing the rights and equities of both the sides can neither it be said to be the error apparent on the face of record nor can be said as an error of jurisdiction. In any case, there is no error of law. 113 31. In the decision of the Apex Court in the case of State of Karnataka, supra, the case before the Apex Court was pertaining to the entitlement in the selection list for the appointment on the basis of the marks secured. The same cannot be equated with the facts of the present case and hence the said decision is of no help to the learned counsel for the employees.

32. Another decision of the Apex Court in State of Uttar Pradesh, the Apex Court itself has observed that the normal Rule is that all similarly situated persons should be equally treated but with the exception in the form of delay, as well as acquiescence. Therefore, it has been observed by the Apex Court that those persons, who did not challenge the wrongful action of their case in acquiescence, woke up after a long delay may be treated differently. We have in the present decision considered the aspect of delay. Under these 114 circumstances and more particularly, keeping in view the facts and circumstances of the present case, we do not find that the said decision would be of any help to the learned counsel appearing for the employees.

33. In view of the aforesaid observations and discussion, the petitions preferred by the respondents as well as the petitions preferred by the employees shall stand dismissed. Sd/- JUDGE Sd/- JUDGE ckl/JT/sd


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organizer Client Files //