Skip to content


Mahantava Irappa Vs. Gangava Mallappa - Court Judgment

LegalCrystal Citation
SubjectFamily
CourtMumbai
Decided On
Judge
Reported inIIIInd.Cas.962a
AppellantMahantava Irappa
RespondentGangava Mallappa
Excerpt:
hindu law - marriage--validity of marriage between different sub-divisions of shudra, tribe--burden of proof. - - ' we must, therefore, hold that the marriage of savakka with basappa was a valid marriage and the appellant's case for that reason must fail......the law as to onus. he says the evidence in this -case certainly does not establish any prohibition of immemorial custom.' we must, therefore, hold that the marriage of savakka with basappa was a valid marriage and the appellant's case for that reason must fail.4. we dismiss the appeal with costs.
Judgment:

1. The question which has been argued before us on behalf of the appellant is whether a marriage between a man of the Panchal caste and a woman of the Kurbar caste is valid. The Panchal and the Kurbars are Sub-divisions of the Shudra tribe.

2. It has been held by the Judicial Committee in Inderun Valugypooly Taver v. Ramasawmy Sandia Taver 13 M.I.A. 141 : 3 B.L.R. (P.C.) 1 : 12 W.R. (P.C.) 41 that when the factum of a marriage is proved the presumption is that it is valid in law and in that case there was nothing illegal in the intermarriage of members of different sub-divisions of a Shudra tribe. The onus would, therefore, appear to lie upon the party alleging an illegality by reason of immemorial custom to prove such prohibting custom. That was the view taken by this Court in the case of Fakirgauda v. Gangi 22 B. 727.

3. The learned District Judge in the case now before us has correctly applied the law as to onus. He says the evidence in this -case certainly does not establish any prohibition of immemorial custom.' We must, therefore, hold that the marriage of Savakka with Basappa was a valid marriage and the appellant's case for that reason must fail.

4. We dismiss the appeal with costs.


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organizer Client Files //