Skip to content


Udai Singh Vs. Bharat Singh and ors. - Court Judgment

LegalCrystal Citation
SubjectCivil
CourtAllahabad High Court
Decided On
Judge
Reported in(1875)ILR1All456
AppellantUdai Singh
RespondentBharat Singh and ors.
Excerpt:
rival decrees - decree of her majesty in concil--decree of the high court--execution of decree. - .....he executed, notwithstanding its execution involves the disturbance of the possession obtained by udai singh under the decree of this court which has become final. the decree of the privy council is the later in date, and had udai singh desired to secure his possession, he should have pleaded the decree of this court in the cross-suit when the suit in which the decree of the privy council has been passed was before that tribunal in appeal.robert stuart, c.j.2. under the peculiar circumstances of this case, i do not think that i ought to withhold my assent to the order agreed to by my colleagues, although i desire to guard myself against the opinion, as matter of law, that the decree of the privy council is as such a bettor decree than the decree of any other court of a prior date and.....
Judgment:

Pearson, Turner, Spankie and Oldfield, JJ.

1. The decree of the Privy Council must he executed, notwithstanding its execution involves the disturbance of the possession obtained by Udai Singh under the decree of this Court which has become final. The decree of the Privy Council is the later in date, and had Udai Singh desired to secure his possession, he should have pleaded the decree of this Court in the cross-suit when the suit in which the decree of the Privy Council has been passed was before that tribunal in appeal.

Robert Stuart, C.J.

2. Under the peculiar circumstances of this case, I do not think that I ought to withhold my assent to the order agreed to by my colleagues, although I desire to guard myself against the opinion, as matter of law, that the decree of the Privy Council is as such a bettor decree than the decree of any other Court of a prior date and which has become final.


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organizer Client Files //