Skip to content


Purun Singh Vs. Dat Ram and ors. - Court Judgment

LegalCrystal Citation
CourtAllahabad
Decided On
Judge
Reported in79Ind.Cas.645
AppellantPurun Singh
RespondentDat Ram and ors.
Excerpt:
pre-emption - sir plots, interest in, nature of--custom--wajib-ul-arz, construction of-- - - unfortunately, the khewat of this village is not on the record, but the sale-deed, as well as the admitted facts, show 'prima facie that these sir plots are within the zemindari of the co-parceners......of the sir plots was not such a transfer of the share in the zemindari as would let in the right of preemption, in favour of a co-sharer. in this view of the matter he dismissed the suit.2. the plaintiff has come up in appeal and challenges the finding of the lower appellate court. unfortunately, the khewat of this village is not on the record, but the sale-deed, as well as the admitted facts, show 'prima facie that these sir plots are within the zemindari of the co-parceners. there is nothing to suggest that they are isolated plots and lie outside the 16-annas share. the point was not seriously pressed at all and was raised for the first time before the learned district judge. we may also note that the case in hazari lal v. ugra rai a.w.n. (1884) 103, relied on by him was.....
Judgment:

1. This is a plaintiff's appeal arising out of a suit for pre-emption. Under a sale-deed dated the 1st of March 1920 certain plots described therein as sir plots -within the Zemindari of the executant were sold to the vendee. A suit was brought to preempt the sale by enforcement of the right of pre-emption. Various pleas were taken in the written statement but at the time when issues were framed by the first Court the denial of the existence of custom does not seem to have been pressed, with the result that there was no issue framed as regards the existence or nonexistence of a custom of pre-emption. The learned Munsif in his judgment did not deal with this matter at all. The suit was decreed. On appeal, the defendants raised before the lower Appellate Court the point, that the wajib-ul arz on which reliance was placed by the plaintiff, did not relate to the sale in question. The learned District Judge, relying on the cases of this Court reported in Saheb Ram v. Kishen Singh A.W.N. (1882) 192, and Hazari Lal v. Ugra Rai A.W.N. (1884) 103, came to the conclusion that the transfer of the sir plots was not such a transfer of the share in the Zemindari as would let in the right of preemption, in favour of a co-sharer. In this view of the matter he dismissed the suit.

2. The plaintiff has come up in appeal and challenges the finding of the lower Appellate Court. Unfortunately, the khewat of this village is not on the record, but the sale-deed, as well as the admitted facts, show 'prima facie that these sir plots are within the Zemindari of the co-parceners. There is nothing to suggest that they are isolated plots and lie outside the 16-annas share. The point was not seriously pressed at all and was raised for the first time before the learned District Judge. We may also note that the case in Hazari Lal v. Ugra Rai A.W.N. (1884) 103, relied on by him was overruled by a Full Bench case reported in Sital Prasad v. Amtul Bibi 7 A. 633 : A.W.N. (1885) 185 : 4 Ind. Dec.(N.S.) 754, and also by another Full Bench case. Safdar Ali v. Dost Muhammad 12 A. 426 : A.W.N. (1890) 117 : 6 Ind. Dec.(N.S.) 1016. It is clear that the interest of an owner in sir plots is a proprietary interest and the transfer of She sir plots is in fact a transfer of his proprietary interest. Under the clause of the wajib-ul-arz, whenever a proprietor transfers his haqiat (property) a right of pre emption accrues. We, therefore, think the suit should not have been dismissed on the ground above mentioned. The result is that this appeal is allowed, the decree of the lower Appellate Court is set aside and that of the Court of first instance is restored with costs including in this Court fees on the higher scale.


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organizer Client Files //