Skip to content


Baidya Nath Mandi Vs. State of West Bengal and ors. - Court Judgment

LegalCrystal Citation
SubjectCriminal
CourtSupreme Court of India
Decided On
Case NumberWrit Petition No. 839 of 1973
Judge
Reported inAIR1974SC1155; 1974CriLJ811; (1974)3SCC489
ActsMaintenance of Internal Security Act - Sections 3
AppellantBaidya Nath Mandi
RespondentState of West Bengal and ors.
Cases ReferredChotka Hembram v. State of West Bengal W.P. No.
Excerpt:
- madhya pradesh uchcha nyayalaya (khand nyaypeeth ko appeal) adhiniyam (14 of 2006)section 2 :[tarun chatterjee & h.l.dattu,jj] writ appeal delay of 589 days in filing - condonation of delay - statements made in application making out sufficient cause for delay delay condoned on condition of payment of costs. .....was in detention, this court gave its judgment in the case of shambhu nath sarkar v. state of west bengal w.p. no. 266 of 1972, dated 19-4-1973 : reported in : [1974]1scr1 . after the aforesaid decision, the state of west bengal directed that the petitioner be released. the petitioner was, accordingly, released on april 25, 1973. the same day, according to mr. chatterjee, a fresh order for the detention of the petitioner was made by the district magistrate burdwan under section 3 of the maintenance of internal security act. the grounds on which the fresh order of detention was made on april 25, 1973, were the same upon the basis of which the earlier order for the detention of the petitioner had been made on december 22, 1971.3. we find that the facts of the present case have a close.....
Judgment:

H.R. Khanna, J.

1. This is a petition for the issuance of a writ of habeas corpus by Baidya Nath Mandi, who has been ordered to be detained under Section 3 of the Maintenance of Internal Security Act.

2. No return in opposition to the petition has been filed, but Mr. Chatterjee on behalf of the respondents has at the hearing admitted the following facts. The original order for the detention of the petitioner under Section 3 of the Maintenance of Internal Security Act was made by the District Magistrate Burdwan on December 22, 1971. The petitioner was thereafter arrested and was kept in detention. While the petitioner was in detention, this Court gave its judgment in the case of Shambhu Nath Sarkar v. State of West Bengal W.P. No. 266 of 1972, dated 19-4-1973 : reported in : [1974]1SCR1 . After the aforesaid decision, the State of West Bengal directed that the petitioner be released. The petitioner was, accordingly, released on April 25, 1973. The same day, according to Mr. Chatterjee, a fresh order for the detention of the petitioner was made by the District Magistrate Burdwan under Section 3 of the Maintenance of Internal Security Act. The grounds on which the fresh order of detention was made on April 25, 1973, were the same upon the basis of which the earlier order for the detention of the petitioner had been made on December 22, 1971.

3. We find that the facts of the present case have a close similarity to those of Chotka Hembram v. State of West Bengal W.P. No. 841 of 1973, D/-29-8-1973 : reported in : 1974CriLJ449 , wherein upon similar facts we quashed the order for the detention of the detenu. Following the aforesaid decision, we quash the order for the detention of the petitioner and direct that he be set at liberty.


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organizer Client Files //