Skip to content


Subba Reddi Vs. Munshoor Ali Saheb - Court Judgment

LegalCrystal Citation
SubjectCriminal
CourtChennai
Decided On
Judge
Reported in(1901)ILR24Mad81
AppellantSubba Reddi
RespondentMunshoor Ali Saheb
Cases ReferredBhagiram Dome v. Abar Dome I.L.R.
Excerpt:
penal code - act xlv of 1860, section 379--removal of fish from an ordinary irrigation tank--charge of theft--maintainability of charge. - - 388 and is answered in the negative, these rulings are evidently referred to by the sub-magistrate, though he has failed to note them with exactness......of such fish constitutes any other offence is fully discussed in bhagiram dome v. abar dome i.l.r. 15 calc. 388 and is answered in the negative, these rulings are evidently referred to by the sub-magistrate, though he has failed to note them with exactness.4. the district magistrate should have referred to them before setting aside the order of the sub-magistrate, following those rulings we must set aside the order of the district magistrate and restore that of the sub-magistrate dismissing the case.
Judgment:

1. The District Magistrate has overlooked the rulings of this Court, dated 23rd October 1878, No. 1759, reported at page 232, Weir's 'Law of Offences,' 3rd edition, and in the note to Queen v. Reva Pothadu I.L.R. 5 Mad. 390.

2. It was there held that fish in an ordinary open irrigation tank are not in possession of any person, so as to be capable of being

3. the subject of theft. The question whether the removal of such fish constitutes any other offence is fully discussed in Bhagiram Dome v. Abar Dome I.L.R. 15 Calc. 388 and is answered in the negative, These rulings are evidently referred to by the Sub-Magistrate, though he has failed to note them with exactness.

4. The District Magistrate should have referred to them before setting aside the order of the Sub-Magistrate, Following those rulings we must set aside the order of the District Magistrate and restore that of the Sub-Magistrate dismissing the case.


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organizer Client Files //