Skip to content


The Empress Vs. Salik Roy - Court Judgment

LegalCrystal Citation
SubjectCriminal
CourtKolkata
Decided On
Judge
Reported in(1881)ILR6Cal582
AppellantThe Empress
RespondentSalik Roy
Cases ReferredAshrof Alt v. The Empress
Excerpt:
penal code (act xlv of 1860), section 211 - charge made on report of police that case was false--charge of giving false information. - .....case of biyogi bhaqut (4 c. l. r., 134), we may point out that it is not in all respects similar to the present case. in that case the complainant, dissatisfied with the police investigation and report, made a complaint to the magistrate, which was dismissed without hearing his witnesses.3. we do not find in the record that there was any complaint made to the magistrate in this case; but on the report of the police that the case was false, the prosecution of the complainant was set on foot. we are unable to say that there is anything illegal in the proceedings, and we are supported in this view by the case of empress v. abul hasan (i. l. r. 1 all., 497). we are not aware of any recent ruling of this court of a contrary tenor. we must, therefore, refuse to quash the commitment on the.....
Judgment:

Mitter, J.

1. This is a reference from the Judge of Sarun asking us to quash a commitment. The ground upon which we are asked to do so is, that the accused, who is charged with an offence under Section 211, Penal Code, should not have been committed for trial until the complaint which he made had been judicially enquired into; and the Judge refers to a case decided by this Court which he considers applies to the present case.

2. If the case referred to by the Sessions Judge is the case of Biyogi Bhaqut (4 C. L. R., 134), we may point out that it is not in all respects similar to the present case. In that case the complainant, dissatisfied with the Police investigation and report, made a complaint to the Magistrate, which was dismissed without hearing his witnesses.

3. We do not find in the record that there was any complaint made to the Magistrate in this case; but on the report of the Police that the case was false, the prosecution of the complainant was set on foot. We are unable to say that there is anything illegal in the proceedings, and we are supported in this view by the case of Empress v. Abul Hasan (I. L. R. 1 All., 497). We are not aware of any recent ruling of this Court of a contrary tenor. We must, therefore, refuse to quash the commitment on the ground on which the Judge's recommendation is based; see Ashrof Alt v. The Empress (I. L. R., 5 Cal., 281).


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organizer Client Files //