Skip to content


Abinash Chandra Mitra Vs. the Emperor - Court Judgment

LegalCrystal Citation
SubjectCriminal
CourtKolkata
Decided On
Judge
Reported in1Ind.Cas.415
AppellantAbinash Chandra Mitra
RespondentThe Emperor
Excerpt:
criminal procedure code (act v of 1898), section 437 - further enquiry--statement of ground. - .....against the accused discharged all of them except 3 under section 253 of the code. the learned sessions judge of birbhum set aside the order of discharge and directed a farther enquiry under section 437 of the code. as regards the petitioner before us, all that the sessions judge says for a further enquiry is this: it will, of course, be the duty of the court below to see whether he could have any 'motive to join in the riot and whether the evidence is sufficient against him.' it was the duty of the sessions judge, before directing a further enquiry as regards the petitioner, to have perused the evidence and stated what the grounds were which induced him to direct a further enquiry. the mere fact that the petitioner was one of the accused would not be sufficient to direct a further.....
Judgment:

1. The petitioner was charged with others with committing an offence under Section 147, I.P.C. The Deputy Magistrate after going carefully through the evidence against the accused discharged all of them except 3 under Section 253 of the Code. The learned Sessions Judge of Birbhum set aside the order of discharge and directed a farther enquiry under Section 437 of the Code. As regards the petitioner before us, all that the Sessions Judge says for a further enquiry is this: It will, of course, be the duty of the Court below to see whether he could have any 'motive to join in the riot and whether the evidence is sufficient against him.' It was the duty of the Sessions Judge, before directing a further enquiry as regards the petitioner, to have perused the evidence and stated what the grounds were which induced him to direct a further enquiry. The mere fact that the petitioner was one of the accused would not be sufficient to direct a further enquiry as regards him, simply because there was such a direction as regards the other accused. We, accordingly, set aside the order of the learned Sessions Judge with reference to the petitioner.


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organizer Client Files //