Skip to content


Jeebunkisto Roy and anr. Vs. Shib Chunder Das - Court Judgment

LegalCrystal Citation
SubjectCriminal
CourtKolkata
Decided On
Judge
Reported in(1884)ILR10Cal1027
AppellantJeebunkisto Roy and anr.
RespondentShib Chunder Das
Excerpt:
discharge of accused - further enquiry, powers to direct--criminal procedure code (act x of 1882), sections 253 and 437. - .....it seems to us that the law allows a further enquiry only where there has not been a full enquiry and where further evidence is disclosed. the application to the judge was to the effect that the evidence recorded by the deputy magistrate was sufficient for the conviction of the accused, and the accused ought to have been convicted. the sessions judge seems to have endorsed the applicant's opinion, and upon that ground ordered the further enquiry. it seems to us that the accused having been discharged after a full enquiry by a competent court, he is entitled to the benefit of that discharge, unless some further evidence is disclosed.2. the order of the sessions judge will be set aside and the proceedings stopped.
Judgment:

Tottenham, J. (Norris, J., concurring)

1. We think that the order of the Sessions Judge directing a further enquiry in this case is not warranted by law. It seems to us that the law allows a further enquiry only where there has not been a full enquiry and where further evidence is disclosed. The application to the Judge was to the effect that the evidence recorded by the Deputy Magistrate was sufficient for the conviction of the accused, and the accused ought to have been convicted. The Sessions Judge seems to have endorsed the applicant's opinion, and upon that ground ordered the further enquiry. It seems to us that the accused having been discharged after a full enquiry by a competent Court, he is entitled to the benefit of that discharge, unless some further evidence is disclosed.

2. The order of the Sessions Judge will be set aside and the proceedings stopped.


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organizer Client Files //