Skip to content


Judgment Search Results Home > Cases Phrase: rationale Court: jharkhand Page 1 of about 288 results (0.030 seconds)

Sep 10 2003 (HC)

Sukhram Singh Vs. State of Bihar (Now Jharkhand) and ors.

Court : Jharkhand

Reported in : [2003(4)JCR457(Jhr)]

..... jharna was available. therefore, the rate of the land under acquisition of village jharna fixed by the collector on the basis of the sale figure of village patrakulhi has its rationale and it cannot be said in the facts and circumstances of this case that the market price of the land under acquisition has been incorrectly and illegally ascertained and it ..... acquired under ext. 2 is fit for building a house thereon and that is why the rate of this land is rs. 250/- per katha. therefore, ext. 2 cannot be rationale of a reasonable basis for determining the market price of the land under acquisition which is either agricultural land of different classification or parti land. therefore, the learned court has ..... . 45,000/- per acres and ail land is rs. 40,000/- per acre and the classification of the land under acquisition has not been made correctly and there is no rationale for the respondent-state to determine the rate of awarding compensation of the land under acquisition and it has been settled by plethora of judicial pronouncements of this court as .....

Tag this Judgment!

Nov 06 2007 (HC)

Tileshwar Sahu Vs. the State of Jharkhand and ors.

Court : Jharkhand

Reported in : [2009(1)JCR242(Jhr)]

..... public relation exercise.the majority of the house of lords in ridge v. baldwin held that non-observance of this principle has rendered the dismissal of chief constable void. the rationale of the majority view is that where there is duty to act fairly, just like the duty to act reasonably, it has to be enforced as an implied statutory requirement .....

Tag this Judgment!

Nov 27 2002 (HC)

Ajay Kumar Kujur Vs. State of Jharkhand and ors.

Court : Jharkhand

Reported in : [2003(1)JCR353(Jhr)]

..... legislative assembly election of the year 1995, i.e., much prior to the appointment of the petitioner.7. the aforesaid stand of the respondents is totally unreasonable, illegal, without any rationale and cannot be accepted by this court.8. this court is also satisfied that the order of cancellation of appointment must also be quashed not only because it is a ..... one lined order without any reasons but also because it is unreasonable and without any rationale. in fact no notice whatsoever appears to have been given to the petitioner prior to the issuance of the aforementioned order. the reasons assigned in the counter affidavit as has .....

Tag this Judgment!

Nov 02 2007 (HC)

Ram Janam Paswan Vs. the State of Jharkhand,

Court : Jharkhand

Reported in : [2008(3)JCR228(Jhr)]

..... appreciate that the appointment under the scheme of compassionate appointment was at the discretion of the authority which was to be exercised keeping in view the scheme and the object/rationale behind it....22. accordingly, the district compassionate committee, after hearing both the parties afresh and allowing both of them to place materials before it, will decide the issue, taking into .....

Tag this Judgment!

Feb 01 2001 (HC)

Nav Chandra Jha Vs. the Presiding Officer and anr.

Court : Jharkhand

Reported in : 2001(49)BLJR714; [2001(89)FLR156]; (2001)ILLJ1464Jhar

..... associated cement co. ltd. v. workmen, smt. saroj arora, c.m.(m) 767/99, judgment, dated 16th november, 2000. their lordships observed :--'it is by now well-known that the rationale behind bar imposed under sub-section (3) was to discourage representation by legal practitioner to ensure expeditious disposal of industrial dispute given regard to the unequal strength of the parties .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jan 14 2015 (HC)

Ranchi University Ranchi Through Its Registrar and Anr Vs. Devashish R ...

Court : Jharkhand

..... in order to arrive at conclusion whether the discretion, exercised by the university resolving that henceforth no grace marks would be given in practical portion of the subject has any rationale in it, even though the reasons are not assigned for arriving at the conclusion, and the answer we get is that the intention behind taking this decision is absolutely ..... cleared all other subjects, therefore, for turning around altogether from the persistent practice having been adopted by the university, for years together, there should have been some cogent reasons or rationale in the sense, otherwise it can be said to be an irrational, unreasoned decision taken by the university, whereas regulation 13(10) of mci regulations of 1997 does not stipulate ..... the subject of medical examinations.11. per contra, mr. tandon, appearing for the petitioner, supported the impugned judgment and submitted that the decision taken by the examination board has no rationale or reasoning as held by the learned single judge inasmuch as the decision taken by the university amounts to re-writing medical council of india regulations, which is beyond the ..... the aforesaid decision taken by the university of not granting grace marks in practical examination observing that the said decision was discriminatory in nature and there appeared to be no rationale in it, being not based on any reason also. it is in this background, the university was directed to award grace marks to the petitioner in practical examination of .....

Tag this Judgment!

Feb 24 2015 (HC)

The State of Jharkhand Through Director Department of Industries Vs. A ...

Court : Jharkhand

..... it viable for commercial production, will 19 not qualify for the incentive subsidy to the tune of rs.15 crores, do not appeal to us at all on a simple rationale that if the said contention is accepted, then the entire provision made for granting incentive subsidy to a mega industrial unit falling in category-iii, would not only become superfluous ..... . he thus submitted that the decision taken by the state government that the incentive could be given only for the clinker and not for cement is not sustainable on any rationale which aspect has been thoroughly dealt with by the learned writ court and ultimately returned a finding against the state which deserves to be upheld.27. joining issue with regard ..... to the question no.ii, learned senior counsel submitted that on this issue also the finding returned by the learned single judge deserves to be upheld on a very simple rationale that may be the chaibasa plant manufactures clinker but clinker is used for manufacturing cement which is the final product. clinker by itself is a raw material is not thrown ..... altogether three different yardsticks for granting incentive subsidy were fixed. learned state counsel submitted that the segregation done by the state for the purposes of grant of incentives has its rationale, otherwise there will be no difference between 'kha' category and 'ga' category in the context of incentive subsidy. learned state counsel submitted that there appears to be no justification for .....

Tag this Judgment!

Feb 24 2015 (HC)

A C C Limited Through Mr Arun Kumar Saxena Vs. The State of Jharkhand ...

Court : Jharkhand

..... it viable for commercial production, will 19 not qualify for the incentive subsidy to the tune of rs.15 crores, do not appeal to us at all on a simple rationale that if the said contention is accepted, then the entire provision made for granting incentive subsidy to a mega industrial unit falling in category-iii, would not only become superfluous ..... . he thus submitted that the decision taken by the state government that the incentive could be given only for the clinker and not for cement is not sustainable on any rationale which aspect has been thoroughly dealt with by the learned writ court and ultimately returned a finding against the state which deserves to be upheld.27. joining issue with regard ..... to the question no.ii, learned senior counsel submitted that on this issue also the finding returned by the learned single judge deserves to be upheld on a very simple rationale that may be the chaibasa plant manufactures clinker but clinker is used for manufacturing cement which is the final product. clinker by itself is a raw material is not thrown ..... altogether three different yardsticks for granting incentive subsidy were fixed. learned state counsel submitted that the segregation done by the state for the purposes of grant of incentives has its rationale, otherwise there will be no difference between 'kha' category and 'ga' category in the context of incentive subsidy. learned state counsel submitted that there appears to be no justification for .....

Tag this Judgment!

Sep 28 2015 (HC)

Durga Thakur and Ors Vs. Personnel and Adminis Reform

Court : Jharkhand

..... and therefore, their candidature should be considered for such recruitment exercise, does not merit acceptance for the simple reason that the fixation of upper age limit is based upon a rationale criteria which is only open to challenge, if it is demonstrably arbitrary and does not have rational nexus with the object sought to be achieved. fixation of upper age limit ..... the fixation of age limit in such recruitment exercise undertaken through public notice, is to be substantiated on the ground that it is either arbitrary and does not have any rationale. on consideration of the grounds urged by the petitioner, it cannot be said that on the ground that the petitioner has completed b.sc,silk technology (sericulture) in 1995 and ..... held by the state of jharkhand for the purposes of filling up the vacancies till the impugned advertisement, the fixation of upper age limit would itself be arbitrary and without rationale. from the rules, it is evident that the reckoning of vacancies are to be done on 1st january of the calender year in which recruitment exercise is done. the age .....

Tag this Judgment!

Sep 02 2013 (HC)

Suman Kumari Vs. Chief Secretory

Court : Jharkhand

..... the reasons discussed hereinabove therefore the insistence upon production of such certificates vide letter no. 584 dated 1st april, 2011( annexure-4), cannot be said to be based upon any rationale justification. therefore the respondents shall not insist upon production of such documents of caste and residence certificate especially issued for employment purposes upon the petitioner as required by the letter ..... based upon two circulars which has been declared as ultra-vires and quashed by special bench of this court. in such circumstances, therefore, the respondents have failed to show any rationale for insisting upon production of such certificates, especially meant for employment purposes. otherwise also the terms of advertisement did not contemplate submission of such certificates of caste and residence issued ..... all such appointed teachers have complied with the said direction, but the petitioner is one, who has resisted the same by not doing so. however, on being asked about the rationale for production of caste certificate and residence certificate, especially for the purposes of employment under the respondents, the counsel for respondents is unable to offer any satisfactory explanation. the certificates .....

Tag this Judgment!


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organizer Client Files //