Skip to content


Judgment Search Results Home > Cases Phrase: rationale Court: karnataka Page 1 of about 966 results (0.008 seconds)

Feb 23 2000 (HC)

K. Narasimha Murthy and Others Vs. Karnataka Public Service Commission ...

Court : Karnataka

Reported in : ILR2000KAR1821; 2000(4)KarLJ97

..... no doubt, what should be the qualification prescribed for a post is within the realm of the rule making authority. but, if the qualification prescribed has absolutely no rationale with the object sought to be achieved and such a qualification results in discrimination or the classification prescribed is unreasonable or arbitrary, certainly this court is entitled to examine ..... rules is only the qualification prescribed for being eligible to be considered for appointment to the post of gazetted probationers. in this background, i do not find any rationale or principle to disqualify persons who possess higher degree than that of a bachelor degree to write either the preliminary or main examination for the post of gazetted ..... like, degree in dental science, medicine and engineering, is treated as the basic qualification for being considered for appointment to the post of gazetted probationers, there cannot be any rationale or principle in holding that the person who possesses postgraduate degree or doctorate degree inthe subjects, like, economics, history, commerce, statistics or sociology, the knowledge of which will ..... the preliminary and final examinations and also the marks obtained in the interview and on comparative assessment of the merits of the candidates; and therefore there is no rationale in insisting that the candidate should possess the basic degree qualification to be eligible for being considered to appear for the examinations. they also submitted that insofar as .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jun 12 2006 (HC)

B. Mahadevaiah S/O Late Basappa Vs. State of Karnataka, Rep. by Its Re ...

Court : Karnataka

Reported in : 2006(6)KarLJ672

..... following:reasons9. the full bench decision of this court in gururaj gurunath govind rao mutalik desai's case has clearly laid down that the full bench cannot subscribe to that rationale in srimanmaharaja niranjan jagadguru mallikarjuna murugarajendra mahaswamy's case reported in ilr 1986 kar. 1059 and has observed as follows in para-16 of the judgment'in srimanmaharaja niranjana jagadguru ..... pointed out therein that the expression rendering an appellate authority as final would be rendered otiose, if it were a subject matter for revision. but we cannot subscribe to that rationale, with respect, because where an order of authority is rendered final whether the same is subject to further revision should be understood in the light of the decisions of the ..... said observations only to contend that revision lies.12. it is clear from the observations culled out above that the full bench has held that it cannot subscribe to the rationale in the decision in : ilr1986kar1059 that when the order passed in appeal is final no revision lies and it has been held that the same has to be considered under .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jan 02 2009 (HC)

Government of Karnataka Represented by Its Principal Secretary, Financ ...

Court : Karnataka

Reported in : ILR2009KAR633

..... collection of tax by the state government on the transaction of sale or purchase of goods, has lead to a chaotic situation and the amendments having been effected without any rationale or justification, has only resulted in arbitrariness rendering ft sub-section (1) of section 72 of the act uncontituonal on the t touchstone of article 14 of the constitution of ..... sub-section (1) of section 72 of the act is no different from those provisions; that the provision of sub-section (1) of section 72 of the act and the rationale for enacting such provision is well supported by a plethora of decided cases and has in this regard placed reliance on the following decisions:tripura goods transport association v. commissioner .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jan 02 2009 (HC)

Philips Electronics India Ltd. Vs. State of Karnataka

Court : Karnataka

Reported in : [2009]20STT314

..... collection of tax by the state government on the transaction of sale or purchase of goods, has lead to a chaotic situation and the amendments having been effected without any rationale or justification, has only resulted in arbitrariness rendering sub-section (1) of section 72 of the act unconstitutional on the touchstone of article 14 of the constitution of india also ..... sub-section (1) of section 72 of the act is no different from those provisions; that the provision of sub-section (1) of section 72 of the act and the rationale for enacting such provision is well-supported by a plethora of decided cases and has in this regard placed reliance on the following decisions:tripura goods transport association's case .....

Tag this Judgment!

Dec 06 1995 (HC)

Sapathagiri Enterprises and ors. Vs. State of Karnataka and ors.

Court : Karnataka

Reported in : ILR1996KAR2991

..... 1991-92, which almost double the rate adopted in the years 1992-93 to 1994-95. some good reasons must have been set forth by the state government supporting the rationale adopted in fixing such fee. unless good reasons are forthcoming, the action of the state cannot be stated to be supported by reason or informed by reason. therefore, we find ..... -92 the same was reduced with effect from 1.7.1992 to rs. 2,50,000/- in respect of distilleries which manufacture any spirit out of molasses. there was no rationale in fixing of this fee for in the previous year it was only rs. 2 lakhs and in the subsequent years it was only rs. 2.5 lakhs while only .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jun 02 1997 (HC)

Dr. Siddalinga Devaru and anr. Vs. Selection Committee, Kidwai Memoria ...

Court : Karnataka

Reported in : ILR1998KAR1556

..... who have served as assistant judges, no such restriction of age has been provided in rule 6(2)(i)(a) and (b) of the said rules. there is obviously no rationale nor any reasonableness for introduction of this age bar in regard to appointment by promotion to the post of an assistant judge. the rule, is. therefore, arbitrary and it violates ..... looked into in the large interest of the public, and in that backdrop, it must be seen as to whether the qualification regarding the age prescribed has any nexus or rationale with the object sought to be achieved. if the entire matter is viewed in the background, what is stated above by me, in my view that the rule which prescribes .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jan 22 1985 (HC)

Bheemanda Devaiah Vs. Kanjithanda Karumbaiah

Court : Karnataka

Reported in : ILR1985KAR3073

..... class of lands merelybecause they form smaller (specific) portions of assessed' survey numbers and are not, by themselves, separately assessed, would amount to denial of well intended benefit with no rationale or logic behind it. after all, it is common knowledge that it is small agriculturists who would very much need the assistance of courts in establishing their claims respecting smaller .....

Tag this Judgment!

Mar 11 1998 (HC)

R. Shankaregouda Vs. the Commissioner of Police, Bangalore

Court : Karnataka

Reported in : ILR1998KAR3141; 1998(3)KarLJ494

..... liquor. it was also contended that music over a cup of tea or coffee is different from music over a drink. i have, i must confess failed to appreciate the rationale behind this reasoning which accepts music as gentle, pure and even sacred but suggests that its benign presence can be tolerated only if no liquor is served in the place .....

Tag this Judgment!

May 25 2016 (HC)

M/s. Manyata Promoters Pvt. Ltd., Represented by its Authorized Signat ...

Court : Karnataka

..... , verandah etc., shall not be ordinarily grouped as buildings. category viii classifies the buildings with central air condition, which is the building for the purpose of classification. a reasonable and rationale classification is to be made before levying tax. it is exclusively permitted for the corporation to classify a building on the basis of its facilities used as it is said .....

Tag this Judgment!

Apr 04 2002 (HC)

Mahadev S/O Narayan Naik Etc. Vs. State of Karnataka and anr. Etc.

Court : Karnataka

Reported in : AIR2002Kant338; ILR2003KAR1724

..... of lands merely because they form smaller (specific) portions of assessed survey numbers and are not, by themselves, separately assessed, would amount to denial of well intended benefit with no rationale or logic behind it. after all, it is common knowledge that it is small agriculturists who would very much need the assistance of courts in establishing their claims respecting smaller .....

Tag this Judgment!


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organizer Client Files //