Skip to content


Judgment Search Results Home > Cases Phrase: rationale Court: madhya pradesh Page 1 of about 613 results (0.041 seconds)

Sep 15 2008 (HC)

M.P. Transport Workers Federation and ors. Vs. State of M.P. and ors.

Court : Madhya Pradesh

Reported in : 2008(5)MPHT374

..... . in the case at hand, the classification has been made between the government sector industries and the non-government industries. there is foundation for the said classification and there is rationale behind the classification between government owned and controlled industries and the industries of the private sector. the other part that certain government industries may be included or the act would ..... . : [1992]2scr780 , their lordships, while dealing with the eligibility criteria, which provide preference to be given to uneducated person over an educated person, came to hold that there is no rationale in adopting such policy and in the absence of any guidelines the selection is entirely left to the whims of the individual officer who holds the interview.41. in premium ..... 14 of the constitution.73. the next submission of the learned counsel for the petitioners fundamentally relates to the absence of rationale paradigm and restriction of industrial philosophy and absence of uniform policy in respect of labour law without any rationale or justification. we have already referred to the industrial philosophy under the central act. in the counter affidavit it has been .....

Tag this Judgment!

May 17 2007 (HC)

Dr. Arvind Bhatia Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh and ors.

Court : Madhya Pradesh

Reported in : AIR2007MP196

..... of marks to a demonstrator up to maximum of 50 marks for 5 years and this provision is clearly violative of article 14 of the constitution inasmuch there is no rationale whatsoever in giving weightage of marks to demonstrators and placing them above the other in-service candidates in the merit list for admission to post graduate medical courses.14. mr .....

Tag this Judgment!

Mar 30 2005 (HC)

Than Singh and ors. Vs. the State of Madhya Pradesh

Court : Madhya Pradesh

Reported in : AIR2005MP170; 2005(2)MPLJ353

..... under authority of other provisions of the constitution such as those in article 332 or clause (f) of article 371f which latter is a special provision for sikkim.120. the rationale and constitutionality of clause (f) and the other provisions of the electoral laws impugned in these petitions are sought to be justified by the respondents on grounds that first, a .....

Tag this Judgment!

Apr 01 2008 (HC)

Dr. Shekhar Seth Vs. M.P. State Bar Council

Court : Madhya Pradesh

Reported in : 2008(5)MPHT42

..... advice v. bar council of india and anr. (supra) has held as under in paragraph 13:13. the next question is, is the rule reasonable or arbitrary and unreasonable? the rationale for the rule, as stated earlier, is to maintain the dignity and purity of the profession by keeping out those who retire from various government, quasi-government and other institutions ..... the age of 45 years and under the impugned rule they are not debarred from practicing. therefore, in the first place there is no dependable material in support of the rationale on which the rule is founded and secondly the rule is discriminatory as it debars one group of persons who have crossed the age of 45 years from enrollment while .....

Tag this Judgment!

Dec 11 1998 (HC)

Gopal Vs. State of M.P.

Court : Madhya Pradesh

Reported in : 1999CriLJ1438

..... before the same bench/judge who dealt with the first application. but we are not impressed. not that we want to break loose or that we fail to grasp the rationale of observations made in these judgments. we only wish to make it clear that observations in these judgments required to be read in their particular context and it cannot be .....

Tag this Judgment!

Feb 26 2001 (HC)

State of M.P. and anr. Vs. Dr. P.K. Shrivastava and 17 ors.

Court : Madhya Pradesh

Reported in : 2001(5)MPHT349; 2001(3)MPLJ1

..... required to be done by their counter parts in arts, commerce and science faculties in government colleges and aided institutions. thus, if the state denies them the equality without any rationale basis, such action definitely amounts to denial of equality before the law or the equal protection of the laws, violative of article 14 and denial of opportunity in matters of ..... the lecturers/professors of college of education for not extending the benefit of revision of pay rules. in the backdrop of the fact that the state has not shown any rationale of its action discriminating one set of employees even before us, we have no option except to reject the state's submission that it could validly not revise the salary ..... colleges and the government aided colleges, in arts, science and commerce faculties, the benefit of 'revision of pay rules' has been given uniformly. the respondents allege that there was no rationale or intelligible criteria behind such a classification. they discharge the same duties, they have the same responsibilities and liabilities as their counter parts in other faculties/colleges of the government .....

Tag this Judgment!

Feb 15 2000 (HC)

Tilak Singh Tomar Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh and ors.

Court : Madhya Pradesh

Reported in : (2000)IIILLJ1344MP; 2000(3)MPHT256; 2000(2)MPLJ249

..... of a decision is the logic and reasoning thereof and not merely its conclusion. the conclusion not preceded by reasoning or rationale cannot be deemed to be having a binding effect as a precedent. a search for the reasoning and rationale preceding the conclusions indicated in the aforesaid decision in the case of suresh kumar kushwah (supra) has gone in vain.59 .....

Tag this Judgment!

Feb 16 2001 (HC)

Jagannath Prasad Vs. State of M.P. and Others

Court : Madhya Pradesh

Reported in : AIR2001MP309; 2001(3)MPHT81; 2001(2)MPLJ542

..... to the retrospectivity of the amendment in question, learned counsel for the petitioner has further submitted that even if it is expressly made to operate retrospectively, keeping in mind the rationale and the benevolent purpose with which the 'niyam, 1972' have been incorporated, such an amendment should not be given effect to because it goes to destroy the very fabric of ..... , spelling out in unambiguous terms the intent in regard to its operation, and the other material available on record were also gone through.4. dilating on the objects and the rationale behind the formulation of the scheme for the benefit of the swatantrata sangram sainik in 1972, the learned counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued that the 'niyam, 1972' were .....

Tag this Judgment!

Feb 24 1995 (HC)

Gautamlal Agrawal Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh

Court : Madhya Pradesh

Reported in : AIR1995MP257; 1995(0)MPLJ858

..... status and stability as in case of general categories. for their general uplift, the scheduled castes and scheduled tribes categories require more protection than the general category and as such rationale of fixing six hectares in case of general category and ten hectares for others cannot be said to be arbitrary.10. lastly, the procedure of assessment is the same as ..... learned counsel is that the criteria for levy on general category as well as schedule castes and scheduled tribes categories suffers from arbitrariness. it is said that there is no rationale in enlarging the holding to ten hectares and not maintaining the same for the general category also. it is a historical fact that members of scheduled castes and scheduled tribes .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jan 25 2008 (HC)

Manoj Kumar Pandya Vs. State of M.P. and ors.

Court : Madhya Pradesh

Reported in : 2008(3)MPHT343

..... shall be awarded for teaching experience in any school. for experience of one year, two years and three years, 05, 10 and 15 marks shall be awarded respectively. there is rationale behind the aforesaid rule also as the teachers who are supposed to teach particular class should have teaching experience of that very level/classes and consequently they are awarded the ..... respectively, as skill required for teaching the aforesaid classes is different. the marks of teaching experience are being awarded on intelligible basis. the qualification that has been prescribed has the rationale behind it of awarding marks of experience to the person who is having the qualification to teach particular class which require different skill otherwise primary teacher would also obtain the ..... education as per notification (r-2) issued on 3-9-2001.4. learned counsel for the petitioners have submitted that the aforesaid rules are discriminatory and differentiation created has no rationale behind it. the qualification of b.ed. is superior qualification as compared to d.ed./b.t.c./d.s.e., thus the weightage ought to have been given at ..... contract teacher grade iii, the qualification for which marks are to be awarded is d.ed./b.t.c./d.s.e., b.ed. has been excluded, there is no rationale behind it. it is further submitted that petitioner has experience of teaching class 9 and 10 but he has not been awarded the experience marks on the basis of class .....

Tag this Judgment!


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organizer Client Files //