Skip to content


Judgment Search Results Home > Cases Phrase: rationale Sorted by: recent Year: 1970 Page 1 of about 140 results (0.008 seconds)

Dec 21 1970 (FN)

Oregon Vs. Mitchell

Court : US Supreme Court

Decided on : Dec-21-1970

..... gillette 58-77. while the reasons for these actions are unclear, it is unlikely that they were provoked by the idea that the fourteenth amendment covered the field; such a rationale seemingly would have made the enfranchising provision itself unnecessary. page 400 u. s. 167 the 41st congress readmitted the remaining three states of the confederacy. the admitting act in each ..... i now read it, gave congressional power under 5 the furthest possible legitimate reach. yet to sustain the constitutionality of 302 would require an enormous extension of that decision's rationale. i cannot but conclude that 302 was beyond the constitutional power of congress to enact. [ footnote 5/1 ] 2 m. farrand, records of the federal convention of 1787, p. 153 .....

Tag this Judgment!

Dec 03 1970 (HC)

Venkitammal and anr. Vs. Janaki Ammal

Court : Chennai

Decided on : Dec-03-1970

Reported in : (1971)1MLJ366

..... the fixation of upset price by the court does not affect the rights of parties and that it is not a judicial act but merely an administrative one. but the rationale of that decision cannot be applied to the facts of this case where the decree-holder has been given permission to bid even in the first sale contrary to the .....

Tag this Judgment!

Nov 19 1970 (HC)

Vyas Gopichand Vs. Mattoo Lal and ors.

Court : Rajasthan

Decided on : Nov-19-1970

Reported in : AIR1971Raj237

..... in the alternative that he had acquired a right of way by prescription through the 'tibara'. it is submitted that the learned senior civil judge did not correctly appreciate the rationale of the decision in kesardeo v. nathmal, air 1966 bom 266, and that the principle laid down in magniram v. rustam, 1961 raj lw 213, and sayrabai v. ahmedji, air .....

Tag this Judgment!

Nov 13 1970 (HC)

Mehrunnisswa Begum and anr. Vs. Government of Andhra Pradesh and ors.

Court : Andhra Pradesh

Decided on : Nov-13-1970

Reported in : AIR1971AP382

..... civil court, whereas the impugned act expressly provides resort to a civil court by any party aggrieved by the action taken under the special enactment. it is urged that the rationale of the decision of the supreme court is founded on the drastic effect of the punjab act which precludes a challenge of the merits of the executive action and decision .....

Tag this Judgment!

Oct 19 1970 (FN)

United States Vs. City of Chicago

Court : US Supreme Court

Decided on : Oct-19-1970

..... of both clearly supports the view of 13a(1) as seeking to remedy state regulatory parochialism. unfortunately, neither quotation speaks to the question put in issue by the court's rationale for summarily disposing of these cases; i.e., whether the congressional decision to proffer an alternative national forum as a remedy for state parochialism is to be construed solely in .....

Tag this Judgment!

Aug 13 1970 (HC)

Bussa Ansuya Vs. Bussa Rajaiaha

Court : Andhra Pradesh

Decided on : Aug-13-1970

Reported in : AIR1971AP296

..... would apply to the case of a consent decree like the decree. which was the foundation of the plaintiff's claim in that suit. it is difficult to understand the rationale of this distinction. whether it is a consent decree or one made or one passed on the adjudication by the court in either case, the question is whether its effect .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jul 17 1970 (HC)

Chhotabhai Purushottam Patel and ors. Vs. the State of Maharashtra by ...

Court : Mumbai

Decided on : Jul-17-1970

Reported in : AIR1971Bom244; 1971LabIC1080; 1971MhLJ413

..... 1/2 to 3 per cent. the contractors, we assume, have long experience of this industry and they know what is a sub-standard beedi. we do not find much rationale for the full 5 per cent chhat. if the experience collected is any guide, the only limit of 5 per cent appears to be a fairly reasonable limit and we .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jul 17 1970 (HC)

Chhotabhai Purushottam Patel, Beedi Manufacturers of Bhandara and ors. ...

Court : Mumbai

Decided on : Jul-17-1970

Reported in : (1972)ILLJ130Bom

..... 2 1/2 to 3 per cent. the contractors, we assume, have long experience of this industry and they know what is sub-standard beedi. we do not find such rationale for the full 5 per cent chhat. if the experience collected as any guide, the outer limit of 5 per cent appears to be fairly reasonable limit and we do .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jul 14 1970 (HC)

State Public Prosecutor Vs. Vilakku Syed Ismail Natchi

Court : Chennai

Decided on : Jul-14-1970

Reported in : (1970)2MLJ552

..... to day, then a fresh offence is committed on every day on which the act of omission continues.justice sadasivan of the kerala high court has approved and followed the rationale of these two decisions. applying this test, there is no difficulty in holding that the respondent-accused was committing a ' continuing offence' from 13th april, 1967, the date of the .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jun 29 1970 (FN)

United States Vs. Sisson

Court : US Supreme Court

Decided on : Jun-29-1970

..... to "settle the law as to future cases of like character. " 41 cong.rec. 2194 (1907) (emphasis added). it is difficult to imagine a case more closely fitting into this rationale than that now before us. the class of nonreligious conscientious objectors is not likely to be a small one. indeed, under the impetus of this holding, it is likely to ..... to a situation that congress clearly intended to reach, the debates appear to contemplate both cases as appropriate for appeal to this court -- certainly the evil aimed at -- and the rationale of the act is broad enough to encompass both situations. appeal was to be for the purpose of deciding "constitutional questions," "questions of law" which, if the district judge's ..... it all of its common law antecedents, and the the present case does not meet the criteria required by the common law. my disagreement with the court's result and rationale is prompted by a fundamental disagreement with the court's mode of analysis and its excessive reliance on ancient practices of common law england long superseded by acts of congress .....

Tag this Judgment!


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organizer Client Files //