Court : Punjab and Haryana
..... , he was not entitled for reinstatement and was entitled only for grant of back kumar amit wages. reliance was placed on the judgment of hon'ble supreme 2013.08.22 10:31 i attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document civil writ petition no.961 o 3. court in secretary, state of ..... entertaining the specious and untenable grounds put forward by the employer public or private. in the judgment of gitam singh's case (supra).the hon'ble supreme court again came to the conclusion observing that therefore, the normal rule that dismissed employee is entitled to reinstatement in cases of wrongful dismissal has been ..... provision which has a beneficial purpose and a public policy behind it would result in nullifying the retrenchment. in devinder singh's case (supra).the hon'ble supreme court in para 13, 19 and 28 of the judgment, observed as under:- 13. the source of employment, the method of recruitment, the terms and ..... difference of one circumstance or additional fact can make the world of difference, as held by the hon'ble supreme court in padmausundra rao and another versus state of tamil nadu and kumar amit 2013.08.22 10:31 i attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document civil writ petition no.961 o ..... 13. others.2002 (3) scc 533. respectfully following the law laid down by the hon'ble supreme court in the above noted cases and applying .....Tag this Judgment!
Court : Mumbai Aurangabad
..... which bail can be cancelled are mentioned. there cannot be any dispute over the propositions made in the aforesaid cases. 24. in the case reported as air 2013 supreme court 296 [kanwar singh meena vs. state of rajasthan and anr.], the apex court has discussed the provisions of section 439 (2) of cr.p.c ..... . with reference to the landmark case of supreme court like ruranvs. rambilas and anr. reportedas air 2001 sc 2023. the observations are as follows : "while cancelling bail under section 439 (2) of the ..... to retain his freedom by enjoying the concession of bail during the trial. in other cases reported as 2009 (2) bom. c.r. (cri.) 491 (supreme court) [manjit prakash and ors. vs. shobha devi and anr.], the apex court has discussed the difference between setting aside unjustified, illegal or perverse order of ..... applicants are the main offenders, this court holds that no bail can be granted to them. so the order. order (i) criminal application nos. 3350/2013 and 1055/2013 stand rejected. rule stands discharged in these proceedings. (ii) criminal application no. 4774/2012 is allowed. the order made by additional sessions judge, ambajogai in ..... c.c. no. 163/2012 dr. smt. mundhe has been behind bars since 3.4.2013. in c.r. no. 42/2012, dr. shri. mundhe has been behind bars since 13.6.2012. bail is refused to him up to supreme court in other case like r.c.c. no. 302/2010. 10. for both .....Tag this Judgment!
Court : Mumbai
..... prosecution case in view of recoveries of other incriminating articles. in this connection, learned app placed reliance on: hemav/s state, through inspector of police, madras (2013 cri. l. j. 1011 (supreme court). the supreme court has held that - ??..... if primacy is given to such designed or negligent investigations or to the omissions or lapses by perfunctory investigation, the faith and ..... of doubt must go to the accused. in support, mr. kulkarni placed vehement reliance on mohd. faizan ahmad alias kalu v/s. state of bihar (2013) 2 supreme court cases 131). in the above authority, supreme court has observed that - ??..... criminal courts recognise only legally admissible evidence and not far-fetched conjectures and surmises. ??....... suspicion, however grave, cannot take the ..... ) vasantasampat dupare v/s. state of maharashtra (2014 air scw 6952), j) the state of maharashtra v/s. raju jagdish paswan (2013 all mr (cri) 1431 (bom), 42. in macchisingh's case (supra), the supreme court justified capital sentence in rarest of rare cases. it was observed that death sentence can be awarded when the collective conscience of the ..... ronny alias ronald james alwaris and others v/s. state of maharashtra (1998) 3 supreme court cases 625), e) swami shraddananda @ murali manohar mishra v/s. state of karnataka (air 2008 supreme court 3040), f) gurvailsingh alias gala @ anr. v/s. state of punjab (air 2013 supreme court 1177), 33. the cases on which the reliance is placed by the learned advocate .....Tag this Judgment!
Court : Mumbai Aurangabad
..... statement of the witness or to contradict him. reliance has also been placed on the case of r. shaji vs. state of kerala, reported in a.i.r. 2013 supreme court, page 651. relevant portion of para 14 and para 15 and 16 are as under: "14. evidence given in a court under oath has great sanctity, ..... accused exhibited the knowledge or the mental awareness of the informant as to its existence at a particular place." it has been further observed by the hon'ble supreme court in the same para that: "....there is one more point which we would like to discuss i.e. whether pointing out a material object by the ..... council in pulukuri kotayya vs. emperor, a.i.r. 1947 p.c. 67. with reference to "discovery of fact" as referred in section 27, hon'ble supreme court observed in para 13 as under: "we are of the view that kotayya's case is an authority for the proposition that 'discovery of fact' cannot be ..... done to impose conviction. as regards discovery, the learned counsel for accused relied on the case of makhansingh vs. state of punjab, reported in a.i.r. 1988 supreme court, page 1705. para 14 of the said judgment is as under: "14. then we are left with the recovery of the dead bodies. investigating officer s. ..... be acquitted. the learned counsel for the accused relied on the case of ram kishan singh vs. harmit kaur and another, reported in a.i.r. 1972 supreme court, page 468, where it has been observed that statement under section 164 of cr. p.c. is not substantive evidence and it can be used only to .....Tag this Judgment!
Court : Chennai
..... consider such submission in the case in (shoraj singh ahlawat and others vs. state of u.p. and another) air 2013 supreme court 52. the honourable supreme court observed that so long as the legal requirement and the settled principles do not permit a discharge, the court would find ..... application seeking discharge. the learned senior counsel for the defacto complainant further submits that the filing of the special leave petition before the honourable supreme court and the undertaking given thereof by the fifth accused have been suppressed in the present criminal revision case by the accused. further, ..... learned senior counsel for the defacto complainant also brought to the notice of this court that in the very same decision, the honourable supreme court also observed that in matrimonial disputes where the allegations relate to continuing offence, the courts has to exercise caution in quashing the criminal ..... the learned senior counsel for the defacto complainant relied on the decision of the honourable supreme court in the case of (shoraj singh ahlawat and others vs. state of u.p. and another) air 2013 supreme court 52 to contend that where the materials placed before the court disclose grave suspicion ..... petition was taken up for hearing on 17.12.2013, it was represented on behalf of the fifth accused that the fifth accused is intending to change some other counsel. subsequently, when the case was listed for hearing before the honourable supreme court on 28.02.2014, an undertaking was .....Tag this Judgment!
Court : Mumbai Nagpur
..... with its hearing. in this regard, he relied upon ashok sadarangani and anr. v. union of india and ors. air 2012 supreme court 1563, manager, national insurance co. ltd. v. saju p. paul and anr. air 2013 supreme court 1064, harbhajan singh and anr. v. state of punjab and anr. air 2009 sc (supp) 1977, and aristopharmaceuticals pvt ..... vs. sarva shramik sangh, sangli air 2014 sc 61 a prayer for postponing consideration of the proceedings was made due to pendency of reference before a larger bench. the supreme court in para 20 observed thus: ??20............................................................................. ................................................................................. as noted earlier, the reconsideration of the wide interpretation of the concept of ??industry ? in bangalore water supply ..... rendered earlier were not modified or altered in any way, they continued to hold the field. similarly, in manager, national insurance company ltd. (supra), the supreme court held that mere pendency of certain questions before a larger bench would not mean that the particular course that was followed in earlier judgments could not be ..... vehicles act, 1988 wherein the accident had occurred in the year 1993, the supreme court adjudicated the proceedings on merits. similar course was followed by the supreme court in harbhajansinghand another (supra). in p. sudhakar rao vs. v. govinda rao (2013) 8 scc 693, the supreme court in para 55 observed thus: ??55. be that as it may .....Tag this Judgment!
Court : Mumbai Aurangabad
..... or lack of resources can never be said to be the reason for not taking steps to implement the proposals, allocations and designations in the development plan. as the honble supreme court has observed that one of the reason which is often given for modification/deletion of reservation is paucity of funds?. if there is any such difficulty, then, the planning ..... any public purpose. in this context, a reference can usefully be made to a recent decision of the honble supreme court in the case of jayeshdhanesh goragandhi vs. municipal corporation of greater mumbai and others, reported in air 2013 supreme court 882. the honble supreme court held as under:- 18. we have already stated that the only question that arises for consideration is whether ..... recent decision in the case of girishvyas and another vs. state of maharashtra and others, air 2012 sc 2043, the honble supreme court had an occasion to consider the scheme of the m.r.t.p. act, 1966. the honble supreme court has held as under:- 73. the provision of a statute are required to be read together after noting the purpose ..... other utilities, services and conveniences. the importance of planning and for the future is emphasized in the judgment of the honble supreme court in the case of padmavs. hiralal motilal desarda and others, reported in air 2002 sc 3252. the honble supreme court held as under:- 29. laws dealing with development planning are indispensable to sanitation and healthy urbanization. development planning comprehensively .....Tag this Judgment!
Court : Chennai Madurai
..... cases 700;(iii) yogesh dutt v. union of india and others reported in 2011 4 adj 78 (allahabad); (iv) union of india v. pankaj kumar srivastava and another reported in 2013 supreme (delhi) 1346; 19. the learned counsel for the petitioner, in support of his submissions, has placed reliance on the following decisions: 20. per contra, mr.s.gurumoorthy, learned standing counsel ..... of the candidates. the court cannot suggest the manner in which the employer should structure or restructure the cadres for the purpose of improving efficiency of administration." 40. the honourable supreme court in the above cited decision held that the court cannot sit in appeal over the judgment of the employer and ordain that a particular post be filled by direct ..... india to do the needful. the said judgment did not have any application to the facts on hand. 39. in union of india v. pushpa rani reported in (2008) 9 supreme court cases 242, the judicial review in respect of matters relating creation/abolition of posts, formation/restructuring of cadres, sources/mode of recruitment, prescription of qualifications, selection criteria, evaluation of ..... decisions. 32. in uni reported in 2009 (14) su which was also cited before the central administrative tribunal and referred to by the tribunal in the impugned order, the honourable supreme court held that where an employer stipulates minimum s andards for promotion keeping in view the safety, security and efficiency, and if the employee is unable to meet the higher .....Tag this Judgment!
Court : Chennai
..... mentioned in the final report. 19. the learned additional public prosecutor for the respondent relies on the decision of the hon'ble supreme court shoraj singh ahlawat and others v. state of u.p. and another reported in air 2013 supreme court at page 52 and at spl. page 55 at paragraph no.11, it is interalia observed as follows: ..... the ambit of ..... special public prosecutor for the respondent / complainant strenuously contends that the police officer, who lodged the fir can investigate and submit a final report as per decision of hon'ble supreme court state by inspector of police, vigilance and anti- corruption, thiruchirappalli, tamilnadu v. jayapaul reported in air 2004 sc 2684. also it is the argument of the learned additional public ..... 197 of cr.p.c., in respect of an offence of cheating etc., on the side of the respondent / complainant, a reliance is placed on the decision of hon'ble supreme court om kr.dhankar v. state of haryana and another reported in 2012 (2) ctc 871. 17. insofar as the aspect of the police officer, who registered the case is .....Tag this Judgment!
Court : Delhi
..... under judicial scrutiny and concluded that judicial review may be called for on two grounds, namely, (i) ?lack of eligibility? and (ii) ?lack of effective consultation?. wp(c) 4653/2013 & 4619/2013 supreme court held that ?eligibility? is a matter of fact, whereas suitability is a matter of opinion. it was further observed that in cases involving ?lack of eligibility? a writ of ..... cag, are subject to scrutiny by parliament or the legislatures of the states, as the case may be. a reference was made to the supreme court decision in the case of arun kumar aggarwal v. union of india: (2013) 7 scale333 where the court held that a cag report, by itself, cannot be accepted by the court as the basis for initiating ..... removal of the cag is different from that of governors of states and akin to that of the judges of the supreme court, the manner of appointment of the cag is similar to that of governors. wp(c) 4653/2013 & 4619/2013 qualification or criteria for an incumbent of the high office of cag. it was submitted that the constituent assembly debates were ..... for the sake of brevity, which indicated congruence of the averments made in wp(c) 618/2007 and the present wp(c) 4653/2013. the learned attorney general submitted that the earlier petitions, which were dismissed by the supreme court, as well as the present petitions, have a common thread apart from having near identical averments and that in this backdrop, the .....Tag this Judgment!